
Today, two different vessels in different parts of the country made two fundamentally different sentences. Evgenia Vasilieva received parole and was immediately released from the colony; Oleg Sentsov and Alexander Kolchenko were sent to prison for 20 and 10 years, respectively.
In the coincidence of these decisions, there was something sinister, almost mystical.
I can’t get rid of the idea that they specially appointed two such vessels for one day. To mate.
- Vladimir Bartholomeev (@varfolomeev) August 25, 2015 The law that the web: the bumblebee will slip, and the fly will be bogged down.
In general, the case of the "Oboronservice", taking into account Serdyukov, who has left responsibility, ends completely tragicomically.
This is not to say that Udo Vasilyeva greatly surprised someone - everything was clearly going to this. But the shamelessness of the execution of many angered.
Damn, Vasiliev was decided to let go immediately. Well this is generally impossible by law. Only after 10 days. That is, right, defiantly.
- Alexey Navalny (@navalny) August 25, 2015Evgeny Vasiliev was released. She will leave the colony today, immediately. I propose to celebrate on August 25 annually as a day of justice!
Today is the day of the triumph of justice: 20 years Sentsov; Udo Vasilyeva, who is probably already flying to the azure shore and a refusal to Udo Swamps Denis Lutkevich.
The thief and bribe taker Evgeny Vasiliev is released. Society remained to rub after the impudent spitting into physiognomy.
Not a day today, but an extravaganza,
And everyone sobs with powerlessness:
Opened wiki, closed Fairy
And she went out at Udo Vasiliev.
Billions were stolen-Serdyukov was amnestied, Vasilieva sat in a 13-room apartment, watched the series, did not appear in the colony and released on the parole for the bedding well ..... you need to start writing a fantasmagoria in the style of Kafka.
That's it, she went out. What a slap in the face of all sitting, not released by UDO, large mothers, heroes of Russia, people who are dependent on old veterans.
About Vasiliev is simply a delightful sequence of events. The heading "How is it possible" at all " pic.twitter.com/kvhzlpgljc
- Maryel (@maryel2002) August 25, 2015
“We will fight corruption sequentially, persistently and hard, the campaign is unacceptable here.” V.V. Putin pic.twitter.com/oi6atkaesk
- Leontiev Victor (@rosagit) August 25, 2015 They raped the right again. It has already died, but they continue to rape
- Pavel Chikov (@pchikov) August 25, 2015 Dad read in the news that Vasiliev was released. And I realized that now he can do everything.
- Son of the Deputy Governor (@zamgubernatora) August 25, 2015 The fact that today was released the thief Vasiliev and condemned the director Sentsov is a deep demonstration of lawlessness. Actually, people like it.
- Mark Feygin (@mark_Feygin) August 25, 2015 It was possible to see the processes of 10 ato for the last couple of years and never and anywhere the authorities were so eager to free the convict as Vasiliev now
- Group War (@gruppa_voina) August 25, 2015 Vasiliev is freed from the parole from the colony, where she, apparently, was not even. Russia is possible!
- Rustem Adagamov (@adagamov) August 25, 2015 The victims in the Vasilyeva case assured the court that they were ready to tolerate
- Funny guys (@vrebyata) August 25, 2015I, in fact, are not bloodthirsty. The fewer people in prisons, the better. The trouble here is different: first Vasiliev (in fact - the switchman), along with her pink slippers, was promoted in all federal television channels. We every grandmother in the village knows more about her personal life than about the fate of his grandchildren. This was an uncompromising, unprincipled, that is, excuse me, a fundamental struggle against corruption. And now - now it ended with such a modest zilch. That is, even with such a clear example, the authorities cannot finish the struggle to the end. Bribe takers and other thieves are not just socially close, it is flesh from the flesh. As you can’t saw off your leg, so you can’t put Vasiliev - let it continue to wrap yourself on the azure shores, we are waiting for fresh photos from Peskov’s yacht. Although, in a good way, not so much she should sit as her high bosses.
What conclusions can be drawn from this sensational business? Several banal ones: “The raven will not turn the eyes of the eye,” the real fight against corruption will change “the fighting of the bulldogs under the carpet” or “the pilles shakes”, etc. We have known all this for a long time.
However, in the fierce “intraspecific struggle” around the Vasilyeva case, new trends were clearly manifested: the warring clans began to act more and more, sometimes not coordinating their steps with the “guarantor”. They themselves “include” the FSIN, command in the courts, the prosecutor’s office, the investigation, that is, they invade the “sacred” sphere of first -person powers.
(By the way, the “Chechen trace” in the case of B. Nemtsov from the same “opera”.)
Different statements (I want to write “testimonies) of various officials and departments only indicates that the security forces no longer know what kind of instruction from the Kremlin is“ true ”, because it is not so easy to double-check them to authenticity. In a word, either “cat for the threshold is mice in dance”, or the entire system really tear off irreconcilable contradictions.
Note that the legal community, fortunately, is not exhausted by Feigin and Chikov. There are completely different opinions of authoritative lawyers.
Barshchevsky lawyer about Udo for Vasilyeva: this is an absolutely legal decision // RIA
- Flashnord (@flashnord) August 25, 2015 Kucherena considers the court decision on Udo Vasilyeva // Interfax justified
- Flashnord (@flashnord) August 25, 2015And then: you just have to hear the arguments of the defense.
Vasilyeva has some kind of continuous fat in the trial. They say that she "participates in concerts and cultural events, neat." They will let her go soon
- Meduza Project (@meduzaproject) August 25, 2015 Vasilyeva is well refueling the bed - the administration of the colony, TASS. The main thing is to season the right bed!
- The fastest elephant (@fastslon) August 25, 2015 Reviews of Vasilyeva from HOAs and a colony - exciting reading http://t.co/qpdzgppsmx
- Vedomosti (@Vedomosti) August 25, 2015Vasilyeva also has public lawyers.
By the way, about Vasiliev (since everyone writes).
I have no objections against her release. Well, in general - because it is not at all interesting to me.
In principle, I seriously do not understand - why should she sit, not Serdyukov - despite the fact that everything is obvious to everyone. Okay, let's say they decided not to plant Serdyukov, - but what does she do? Well, at least one normal person can think that "this is she, but Serdyukov did not know"? And that Serdyukov did not decide everything? Well, not fools. And the principle of "at least Vasiliev" - I do not like categorically.
I am not at all interesting to me, I repeat; In addition to the fact that she was invented by cool PR.
I remember the role of Serdyukov in the Yukos case, but our troubles are not a reason to wish the other one. Vasilieva now also drank. Congratulations to her on liberation!
- Khodorkovsky Mikhail (@Mich261213) August 25, 2015 Reading the tape about Vasiliev: the most filthy that this power did was firmly settled cruelty in the souls and to its supporters and opponents!
- Khodorkovsky Mikhail (@Mich261213) August 25, 2015Someone habitually (in order not to say doomedly) is boring:
Right now, the employees of the Vladimir colony are issued a passport so that they can fly to Vasilyeva and free it at parole.
- Uncle Shu (@shulz) August 25, 2015
Soon Evgenia Vasilyeva in Nice will come to the pleasant news that she was released from the colony by parole.
- Corner of cynic (@Cynicarea) August 25, 2015 Vasiliev is released so that she can buy dollars. We are not animals.
- Peskova's mustache (@sandy_mustache) August 25, 2015 Let Vasiliev go immediately so that she managed to sell.
- sanctions fruit (@judge_syrova_ya) August 25, 2015 Three hours after the release, Vasilieva Zadkkochkin on the Maltese Falcon yacht.
- The same Ternovsky (@dternovskiy) August 25, 2015 Why did Nobody asked Venediktov if there was Vasiliev in the colony all this time? He probably knows exactly what was.
- iVan davydov (@ivan_f_davydov) August 25, 2015 "The court ordered Vasiliev not to appear in public places in a state of alcohol and narcotic intoxication." Here are the animals.
- iVan davydov (@ivan_f_davydov) August 25, 2015 Vasiliev and Serdyukov stole billions. Proven by the court. Not a day for a day. And the fifth column and traitor of the homeland are still you
- Dmitry Sukharev (@d_suharev) August 25, 2015 They say that in general there was a decree to unlock Vasiliev, the Wikipedia was mistakenly captured.
- Wylsacom (@wylsacom) August 25, 2015A separate and, in its own way, a very charming gap of the template - with the patriotic public.
Readers of the Lifenews website broke about news about Vasiliev and UDO. Bring new ones. pic.twitter.com/ii5qz2SLKM
- Mikhail Roskin (@roskin_m) August 25, 2015
Long live our court! The most humane court in Mirena, if your surname Vasiliev. The rest of the text, I, so as not to swear in TWI, I am eagering.
- Vladimir soloviev (@vrsoloviev) August 25, 2015 Pipipipipipipipipipipa, the court released Pipipipipipipipipipipipipipi Vasiliev. Are they there Pipipipipipipipipipipipipipip?
- Vladimir soloviev (@vrsoloviev) August 25, 2015 When I evaluate the situation with the liberation of Vasilyeva, I agree with Gleb Zheglov. The thief must be in prison. Even if I returned stolen
- Nikolay Starikov (@nstarikov) August 25, 2015 I wonder what sentence would Madame Vasilieva receive for the same acts in China? It’s even scary to imagine ...
- Igor Korotchenko (@i_korotchenko) August 25, 2015 The question is to those who were lobbying Udo Vasilyeva - are you working against GDP?
- Igor Korotchenko (@i_korotchenko) August 25, 2015 The liberation of Vasilievskaya Medvedev liberals once again cynically rudely abused not even over justice, but over the very idea of the law
- Mikhail Delyagin (@delyagin) August 25, 2015 Oleg Mironov sat down for three years http://t.co/p4lvriu3hs , and Evgenia Vasilieva was released at UDTPS ://t.co/gvqusucjay . Ambassador Tefft is satisfied?
- Gennady Zyuganov (@g_zyuganov) August 25, 2015The last tweet, of course, is the strongest - what does the US Ambassador have to do with it, it is strongly impossible to understand.
Someone, seriously or jokingly, suggests talking about the merits of Evgenia Vasilyeva:
If not for Vasiliev, you would not have green men. Crimea would be taken drunken lawsuit for the sake of stained warehouses.
- La Russie Parle (@russia_calls) August 25, 2015 In fact, Vasilieva is an ordinary blonde who was supposed to fulfill her narrow function in a large state of state to re -engage in the army and reformat the economy of the Ministry of Defense, and the will of fate was destined to get into a media alteration of a federal scale. Which, in fact, does not correspond to her status, mind, nor the scale of her guilt.
I repeat what I have repeatedly spoke about this earlier-the military reform was conceived and initiated personally by Vladimir Putin, it was broken several times due to the opposition of the brave generals of the late 80s-90s, and therefore the contractor was finally chosen for the army and Bulldozer Serdyukov. His task was to push the generals and the General Staff from the flow of money, to clear the site for indigenous transformations. Naturally, for this, he set up his people - financial girls to key posts. But this ultimately justified itself. Serdyukov would not be - there would be no new modern high -class army. It was under Serdyukov that the military began to receive a lot of money, and the units began to be re -equipped. Next, the process of Shoigu completed the process, taking up the organization of the military structure directly.
Vasilieva is a brilliant scam. For 20 years, plowing the army was written off on a woman who did not even sit! Billions are assigned. The case is closed. All!
- Joseph Stalin (@stalingulag) August 25, 2015 This is where 100% consensus in society is in the Vasilyeva case! I can’t find a single approving comment even on the Lifeyuz website
- Vladislav Naganov (@naganoff_ru) August 25, 2015 Such a blow to Putin’s rating as the liberation of Vasilyeva could not have inflicted his enemy. Although court sociologists can bleat the opposite
- Vladislav Naganov (@naganoff_ru) August 25, 2015 I get great pleasure from reading comments on the indignant "patriotic" public about Vasilyeva - in the comments on the news of the RIA and other state resources, as well as in private blogs.
Very funny things write - how, they say, so? The people are against, the thief must be in prison!
Naive are such, directly laughter and sin.
For the close circle of Putin V.V., as well as for friends of his friends and their mistresses, no laws are written. They can do everything and nothing will happen for it.
Therefore, Yakunin receives the rank of ambassador, and Vasilieva is completely corrected in the colony in a month.
What is a lot today is comparisons of different court decisions. These comparisons do not please anyone.
I really want to remind you that exactly today they refused Udo Lutskevich sitting in the swamp business. Right now, in the same case, they are judged by the non -refunding with the accusation "grabbed the policeman by the wrist."
Vitishko, who was sitting on the inscription Sanya-thief on the fence of the governor's cottage, refused UPO, because he poorly laid tomatoes.
Well, Oleg Navalny meets the liberation of Vasilyeva in a single schizo, where his bed is fastened to the wall at 4-30 in the morning and you can either walk on a chamber of 1.5x5 meters until night, or sit on a stool. For six months of imprisonment, Oleg has three penalties.
Still, you can’t get away from traditions. Remember from Solzhenitsyn that in Soviet camps, Vertukhay had a completely different attitude towards political and “socially close”. The latter included thieves, killers and other criminals.
“Socially close” to our authorities to his theft, Vasiliev is released by parole.
Political - Evgeny Vitishko fought theft. On the fence of Latifundia, the Tkachev family, who fenced a huge territory on the Black Sea coast, he wrote: "Sanya is a thief."
But he was refused UPO for sharing with another prisoner his sweater, he did not say hello for the second time with the boss and “incorrectly weeded tomatoes”, etc., etc.
The release of Vasilyeva by UPO is another indication to the society to his place - literally in the camp parach.
Gaskarov, Vitishko, Lutskievich - the court objects to Udo Vasiliev - the court does not object to Udo, you see what statistics? 25% get parole!
- Vsevolod Chernozub (@vissevald) August 25, 2015 Vasiliev was released today at parole, and Sentsov will be given Sentsov for 20 years now. And who has inflicted more damage to Russia?
- Gantenbine (@a3ap) August 25, 2015 To Vasilyeva. For some reason, I remembered that grandmother, a blockade who was accused of stealing packs of oil.
- Just ❤️ Mila (@Prostomilochka) August 25, 2015 Vasilieva comes out ato, the world will never be the same. Stole chicken? Hold 7 years! Stole billion? Hold on your parole!
- Sultan Khamzaev (@sultanhamzaev) August 25, 2015 Vasilieva for 550 million served 109 days - one day for 5 million. Yaroslav Belousov served for 2.5 years for an abandoned lemon
- George Alburov (@alburov) August 25, 2015 But the patient with cystic fibrosis Anton Lanshakova is not released from the colony for a week, despite the court’s decision. Sudia does not send him to the colony
- Pavel Chikov (@pchikov) August 25, 2015 Rob the country for billions - to the hands of knocking a policeman on the hands - 5 years of colonies without parole. Glory to the Fatherland our free
- Putin's back (@spina_putina) August 25, 2015 Bakhmina with the children twice refused UPO. Swamps are denied. And Vasilieva, who sat mainly not in the cell, but at home, immediately received parole.
- Alexander Shurshev (@shurshev) August 25, 2015 Ksenia Sobchak became the object of indignation in social networks, and Evgenia Vasilieva, who stole billions and did not immediately go on parole.
- Revolutionary thoughts (@vvp2_0) August 25, 2015But even more than Udo Vasilyeva echoes another decision that the Russian court made on the same day - with monstrous prison dates Sentsov and Kolchenko.
The Russian “court” fired today in a society from a double -barreled gun.
Two of his decisions - the liberation of E.N. Vasilyeva and condemnation for 20 years O.G. Sentsova and A.A. Kolchenko is not just another visual lesson for citizens that the Russian “court” as a legal institution does not exist. <...>
The meaning of what happened today is in the unprecedented arrogance - making two defiant decisions in one day. At the same time, this is an open insult of citizens thinking about their country - they hit them first on one cheek, and then on the other. “Hove to you, wash! This is from Vasilyeva, and this is for Sentsov! We are doing here, everything we want! And you won’t do anything against us! ”
In value, what happened is second only to the murder of A.S. Politkovskaya and B.E. Nemtsov.
Who will explain to me why to put Sentsov for 20 years (what kind of special danger does he represent?) And at the same time releasing millions of Vasiliev, who, by the way, was never discovered in any prison, it seems and did not sit. Why irritate people like that? It seems to me that our power has not just a bad PR service, but all of the enemy agents is 146 percent.
A monstrous verdict sentenced on the basis of indications, including knocked out under torture, this is pure water.
- Vladimir Bartholomeev (@varfolomeev) August 25, 2015
Salman Radueva Auski received the associate of Salman Raduev for participation in a terrorist attack in Kizlyar (115 victims, of which 104 military personnel and employees of the Ministry of Internal Affairs)
- Tatyana Solomina (@solominatiana) August 25, 2015 They captured someone else's land, grabbed the local disagreements with occupation, tortured and demolished demonstratively for 20 years. I live in a Nazi state
- Roman Dobrokhotov (@dobrokhotov) August 25, 2015 Sentsov for arson of the door of United Russia - 20 years. Kadyrov for participating in the war against the Russians - the presidency, the title of a hero, immunity, money
- Ruslan Leviev (@ruslanleviev) August 25, 2015 That is, Girkin is not a terrorist, but Sentsov terrorist.
- Anatoly Kravchenko (@tikaipo) August 25, 2015 For 20 years, Sentsov and Udo Vasilyeva once again confirm the obvious fact - there is no court in the Russian Federation and there will be no under the ruling regime.
- Nikolai Polozov (@moscow_advokat) August 25, 2015 Kleptopashism in Russia will live a maximum of another two years. I am sure that in a couple of years Oleg Sentsov will make new films.
- Hugo Karlovich (@jon_tm) August 25, 2015Реакция официальных лиц: от президента Украины до американского посла в Киеве:
Тримайся, Олеже. Прийде час, і ті, хто організував над тобою судилище, самі опиняться на лаві підсудних! pic.twitter.com/GwBTIIgSuh
— Петро Порошенко (@poroshenko) 25 августа 2015 20 років? Вирок Сенцову і Кольченку? Ні,це вирок Росії. І Сенцов,і Кольченко, і Крим будуть вільними значно раніше.От чи буде Росія -питання
— Yevgen Perebyinis (@YPerebyinis) 25 августа 2015 Решительно осуждаю судебный фарс в РФ, который завершился сегодня тюремным приговором для #Сенцов %27а и #Кольченко . Постыдное решение.
— Geoffrey Pyatt (@GeoffPyatt) 25 августа 2015Кто-то находит в себе силы покуражиться и здесь.
- Слава Украине, - сказал Сенцов. - Героям слава, - ответил Кольченко. - 25 лет строгача, - взоржал судья.
— Совестливый Комиссар (@sibiliznew) 25 августа 2015 Сенцову дали 20 лет. Right! Человек, который назвал русских оккупантами Крыма заслуживает двадцатки,урод!Украина 23 года насиловала Крым
— Эдуард Лимонов (@edvlimonov) 25 августа 2015 Мы Крым завоевали при Екатерине,а Украина его сшахрайствовала у нас,выдурила у Ельцина-алкаша.Пусть сидит Сенцов за ворованное русское добро
— Эдуард Лимонов (@edvlimonov) 25 августа 2015 У бывш. писателя Лимонова ускоренный какой-то курс оскотинивания, похоже. Новые таблетки.
— ivan davydov (@ivan_f_davydov) 25 августа 2015Суд приговорил Олега Сенцова и Александра Кольченко к 20 и 10 годам колонии строгого режима.
Нужно понимать, что приговор Сенцову - это самый лютый и жестокий приговор, вынесенный Кремлем ПОЛИТИЧЕСКОМУ врагу за всю постсоветскую историю. Ну приморские партизаны еще были, да.
После оглашения приговора Сенцов и Кольченко начали петь гимн Украины прямо в зале суда.
Эдуард Лимонов публично радуется "двадцатке" для Сенцова. Лимонов - это российский политик, сам обвинявшийся по целому букету тяжелейших статей (в том числе и по терроризму), прокурор просил для него 14 лет, но Лимонов получил 4 года, вышел по УДО через два года и три месяца. В период своего заключения он пел несколько иные песни - например в хоре самодеятельности в колонии, исполнял произведение "Ничего на свете лучше нету" из мультфильма "Бременские музыканты". Выйдя на свободу, Лимонов отправил многих партийцев на чреватые многолетней тюрьмой акции прямого действия, и Украина, Родина Олега Сенцова, спасала этих ребят от тюрьмы, давала им убежище.
Пока Сенцова увозил в тюрьму автозак, Евгения Васильева, высокопоставленная чиновница Минобороны, бесстыжая коррупционерка, освобожденная из владимирской колонии по УДО, загружала свою тушу в автомобиль, отчаливала обратно в Москву.
Никакого вывода делать я не буду, это уже бессмысленно. Просто очередной безумный день жизни обезумевшей страны.
This is madness. Потому что даже если верить версии обвинения и считать, что Сенцов вместе с Кольченко, Афанасьевым и Чирнием участвовал в подготовке взрыва памятника Ленина, который не получился… Ну и там еще офис «Единой России», русской общины в Крыму с ущербом в 30000 рублей… То это трудно квалифицировать как теракты, потому что при них не только никто не пострадал, но и не должен был пострадать.
Россия аннексировала Крым, мир с этой аннексией не согласен. Мне лично глубоко стыдно, что моя страна наказывает людей на 20 лет за то, что они, не угрожая человеческим жизням, оставались патриотами Украины.
Кремль будет, видимо, торговать Сенцовым как заложником. Точно так же, как Кохвером и Савченко. Это то, что Кремль понимает под международной политикой – торговля заложниками. Другие государства понимают международную политику иначе. И договориться будет трудно. Потому что другие государства считают, что заложниками торгуют террористы, а не цивилизованные государства.
Посмотрев выступление Сенцова, я сказал, что когда на скамье подсудимых, — а я верю, что это случится, — окажутся те, кто фабриковал это дело, кто давал заказ и его исполнял, — у них мы не увидим ни капли его достоинства. Они будут врать и изворачиваться, валить вину на других, объяснять, что они „люди маленькие“, от которых „ничего не зависело“, у них „не было другого выхода“, они только „выполняли приказ“, и вымаливать себе каждый лишний месяц смягчения приговора.
„Не судите, и не судимы будете“, — сказано в одной из самых знаменитых книг в истории человечества.
„И судимы будете“, — хочется сказать тем, на чей совести приговор Олегу Сенцову и Александру Кольченко.
Количество судебных процессов в отношении инакомыслящих будет расти. Следствие начнет просто «на автомате» использовать эфесбешные ноу-хау для получения нужных доказательств, результаты ОРМ (оперативно-розыскных мероприятий) будут ложиться в обвинительные заключения без соблюдения правил их оформления, как это сделано в деле Сенцова и Кольченко. Так, впрочем, делалось и раньше, но, поскольку дела были не столь резонансные, общество об этих способах создания уголовных дел особенно не знало.
Приготовиться всем, кому не нравится, что растет доллар, кому нравится, что растет доллар, кому не нравится, что сжигают продукты, кому не нравится Путин или Медведев, кому не нравится отсутствие свободных выборов, — если очень надо, вас посадят. Суд будет псевдо-открытый, прокурор попросит 20 лет, судья даст 15 лет, и все вздохнут с облегчением.
«Мне стыдно», — пусть это говорит российский полицейский или фээсбэшник. «Мне стыдно», — пусть это говорит российский судья. «Мне стыдно», — пусть это говорит депутат Государственной думы или сотрудник администрации президента. Но не гражданин. Стыд — это форма солидарности. Вы уверены, что российское государство заслуживает вашей солидарности с ним?
Просто перестаньте относиться к Российской Федерации как к своему государству. Оно не ваше, не наше. Оно село нам на голову, не спросив нас, хотим ли мы этого. Оно существует независимо от нас, единственная форма его взаимодействия с нами — его полицейские структуры. Тот человек, которого убили в ОВД «Дальний» — если бы он был жив, он бы тоже говорил, что ему стыдно за полицейских?
Пусть за Российскую Федерацию будет стыдно Российской Федерации — она не мы, она не имеет к нам отношения. Это чужое государство, оно враждебно любому русскому человеку. Говоря, что вам за него стыдно, вы встаете на его сторону. Относитесь к нему, как к ИГИЛу — вам стыдно за ИГИЛ? Я полагаю, что ИГИЛ должен вызывать какие-то другие сильные чувства по отношению к нему. Попробуйте сформулировать эти чувства хотя бы мысленно. Что это будет — наверное, ненависть, наверное, страх.
20 лет - это очень много времени, особенно если их сидеть. Никаких способов подать апелляцию ни по Сенцову, ни по Кольченко, ни по Савченко у нас нет. Будут сидеть либо всю жизнь, либо до крушения путинского режима, смотря что раньше наступит.
Отсюда вывод - цели определены, за работу.
Когда судья спросил у Сенцова и Кольченко, понятен ли им приговор, они стали петь гимн Украины.


Social Networks Editor Radio Liberty