Translated material
Giblets "God's will"
How does the organization of Dmitry Enteo function, who patronizes it?
Until recently, the organization of God's will, headed by Dmitry Tsorionov (Enteo), few perceived seriously. The buffoonery shares of Orthodox militants were quickly forgotten for NTV reporters and boulevard newspapers. However, the attack on the exhibition in the Manege, where Vadim Sidur's works were damaged, showed that God's will has influential patrons. The pogrom participants were detained for a while and immediately released from the police, although all evidence of their guilt was evident. Dmitry Tsorionov, without fearing anything, gives comments to journalists and approves other similar stocks , such as vandalism in St. Petersburg and a re -attack on the “arena”. Why does the state, whose ownership was committed, is in no hurry to punish vandals? How do street clowns conclude an alliance with the authorities? To answer these questions, you should study the history of "God's will."
The culturalist Anna Brazhkina first became interested in Tsorionov-Enteo in 2012, when she made his short biography for the “ Forbidden Art ” website. Rostov journalist Kirill Krivosheev, who studied the activities of associations fighting abortions, joined the "God's will" and spent a month a member, studying the activities of the organization from the inside .
On the air of Radio Liberty, Kirill Krivosheev and Anna Brazhkina are thinking about how the Enteo phenomenon was born.
- Why are you interested in Enteo? Do you consider him a curious character or a dangerous person who needs to be stopped?
Anna Brazhkina: In 2012, when I made the first, dotted biography of Enteo, he was just one of about 40-50 Orthodox activists who constantly participated in the Moscow aggressive street policy around the Pussy Riot case. Most of them previously smashed exhibitions, attacked LGBT and eco -activists, seized cultural sites, and certainly used knives in a street war with Antif.
Often he called the police before the fight itself began
But it was Enteo, before others, who made the “permissible”, as he believed, the violence and intimidation of opponents with the key technical technique of his field political activity. For three years-from May 2012 to July 2015-he participated in about 60 cases of the "political struggle" using violence, and in half of these cases he himself was their main organizer.
Almost always, except for one case, small brawls arose from its presentation. Enteo did not hide that he provokes fights consciously: this allowed him to call for help the police. Often he called the police before the fight itself began. When in a brawl he got a significant blow in the eye or on his ear, he was pleased: you can write an application for specific offenders. In the legal sense, this technique was ineffective: the police were usually limited to "educational conversations" with brawls. But a spectacular "Press picture" was created.
I do not think neither a bright person nor a particularly dangerous entity of Enteo - completely different people set a common frame in the “street policy design”. Enteo, while slightly going beyond the boundaries of the law, simply creates tender information and pictures. But this technique is too well known without it, there is nothing unique in it. The main value of Enteo for the researcher is that, walking along his "thread", theoretically you can reach the "people who make decisions."
The illegal actions of Dmitry Enteo and its struggle for the establishment of Orthodox censorship. Chronology prepared by Anna Brazhkina
May 19, 2012. Participation in a group attack on a nomadic museum
May 25, 2012. Participation in the dispersal of the rally LGBT
June 20, 2012. Participation in the brawl near the Tagansky court, earheads
August 17, 2012 . Group " Cap" to journalists in the cafe "Mu-Mu"
August 18, 2012. Participation in the hint of the Khamovniki court
August 27, 2012 . Group attack on Alexei the Summer -Sentinet sitting on the train
August 28, 2012. Promotion at Teatar.doc against the performance in support of Pussy Riot. Application for the creation of the organization
August 29, 2012 . The capture of the erotic museum "Tochka-g"
August 31, 2012. Participation in the information campaign "Double murder in Kazan, a supporter of Pussy Riot"
September 6, 2012. A statement to the prosecutor's office regarding the action of the War Art Group in the Auchan store
September 8, 2012. An attack on Enteo opponents of the construction of the temple on the Khodynsky field
September 18, 2012. Storm of the Clinic "Santanna"
September 20, 2012. Participation in the capture of the "Vinzavod", where the exhibition "Spiritual Branch" is held
September 24, 2012. The capture of the theater.doc (play "with its own eyes")
September 20, 2012. Participation in the opening of the exhibition Evgenia Maltseva " Spiritual Branch "
October 7-8, 2012. Telephone threats and a statement to the prosecutor's office for Artemy Lebedev (regarding the "blasphemous" competition he declared)
October 2012. Participation in the capture of a gay club
October 17, 2012. Peak "Artoal Career" Enteo - Preparation of an exhibition of radical Orthodox art (together with Dmitry Pimenov and Konstantin Starchedovtov)
September 8, 2012. Enteo is beaten on the Khodynsky field while trying to disperse the promotion against the construction of the temple
November 19, 2012. Picket against evolutionism in schools
December 12, 2012 . Attack on the pickets of the State Duma against anti -Sirot and antihean law
December 14, 2012. The capture of the Sakharov Center, where the exhibition "to Russia with love" takes place
December 19, 2012. Participation in the attack on the participants of the Promotion "Kiss Day"
January 25, 2013. Participation in the attack on the participants of the second action "Kiss Day"
January 28, 2013. A statement to the prosecutor for a home-X teacher.
February 5, 2013. A statement to the prosecutor's office for the teacher of the Lyceum "Second School" I. Kolmanovsky
February 5, 2013.
March 1-3, 2013. Participation in the performance of Milo Rau. Attack on the performance of the Cossacks
March 10, 2013. The second capture of the Erotic Museum "Point G"
March 14, 2013. Capture of the Office Office, Book Autodafe
March 16, 2013. Capture of the Darwin Museum
March 28, 2013. Participation in the attack on the "Sect of God Kuzi"
April 1, 2013. "Moleben" on the intelligence of Mitrokhin
April 8, 2013. A statement to the police and the department of E against the sect of Scientology
June 11, 2013. Prevention of the LGBT action
June 2013. An application to the prosecutor's office of the Perm Territory on Marat Gelman
June 20, 2013. Clinic capture on Tverskaya-Yamskoye
June 27, 2013. "Promotion" against the sect Guru Sri Chinmoy
July 17, 2013. "Promotion" against the magazine "Flirt"
July 26, 2013. An attempt to capture the office of Nestle ("Against Cannibalism")
August 17, 2013. Participation in the dispersal of the event "Flying Macaron Monster"
August 17, 2013. Participation in the attack on the procession of the Pastafarians
November 28, 2013. A fight on the stage of the Moscow Art Theater B.P. Chekhov during the play "Perfect Husband"
December 13, 2013. The pogrom of the exhibition dedicated to the adoption of children with homosexuals
December 19, 2013. "Enjoying" shares of LGBT "Kiss Day"
January 20, 2014. Beating Dmitry Davydov, the former head of the Chaplin press service, for an article with strict criticism of order in church life
May 19, 2014. The persecution of "God Kuzi" (together with NTV)
July 27, 2014. An attack on a group of musicians Marilyn Manson, a breakdown of a concert.
August 26, 2014. The threat of disrupting the concert tour in Russia of the Cannibal Corpse group
September 19, 2014. Participation (together with Milonov) in an attack in St. Petersburg on Quir-Fest
October 2014. The capture of the Sakharov Center, where the LGBT community event took place
November 3, 2014. Application to the prosecutor's office for the Sodom group, the abolition of the concert
December 4, 2014. Capture of the School of Rodchenko, spraying hydrogen sulfide
January 19, 2015. Participation in the attack on the anti -fascist marketing marketing markel and Baburova memory
April 1, 2015. Pork head under the Tabakov Theater
April 6, 2015 . Threats "male conversation" to Kirill Frolov
May 5, 2015 . Applications to the prosecutor's office for Sobchak because of her photo in the image of a priest
May 19, 2015. The requirement of the ban on Eurovision and the withdrawal of Polina Gagarina from the competition
May 30, 2015. Participation in the attack on gay parade
June 21, 2015 . Participation in the confrontation on the peat
Since June 2015 . Activist participation in the promotion of the law on the equality of communism and Nazism
Since June 2015. Information participation in the promotion of the removal of the moratorium on the death penalty
- Is it possible to call the "God's will" the classic sect: the Prophet and the ecstatic flock that listens to his every word?
Orthodox native of Kenya should be closer to you than your neighbor - Russian atheist
Kirill Krivosheev: I don't think this is a sect. People in God's will, whatever the charismatic and authoritative figure of Dima Enteo himself, still obey the Russian Orthodox Church and consider Patriarch Kirill to be their spiritual leader. There are priests and there are spiritual fathers whose views they do not share. For example, their main opponent is Andrei Kuraev. On the Internet you can find hot disputes between Enteo and Kuraev. Kuraev adapts classical Orthodoxy to our modern life realities. This from the point of view of Enteo is unacceptable. He is for Orthodoxy, which was in the Middle Ages. Enteo also supports uranopolitism, a course that puts religion at the forefront. For example, so that it is religion to be the main criterion of a person. That is, the Orthodox native of Kenya should be closer to you than your neighbor - a Russian atheist. They have a thesis: who is the Motherland Mother, God is not a father. It sounds very defiant, but it is.
Dmitry comes from "gilded youth"
If the main enemy is Kuraev, then the main friend is Archpriest Chaplin. But there are smaller fathers who support them. We had meetings in temples. Just a car drove up to the temple, we got there and drove to some kind of action. Dima once told us: “But they told me that at a meeting in the Synod, the Patriarch told me that he appreciates“ God's will. ”But I think that this is far from the truth, because the statements of rather high-ranking people in the Russian Orthodox Church are known, who said that they relate to this very, very warily. I can say as a Rostov, for his Metropolitan Mercury, he is for one of the public. The events were asked how he relates to "God's will." This can be called blasphemy. "
- There are many rumors about Enteo's guardian life. What family is he, and is it true that he was a member of the Hindu sect?
Anna Brazhkina: his father, Sergey Tsorionov, a graduate of MGIMO and a candidate of sciences, after the birth of his son (and the collapse of the USSR) was the head of the economic department of the Russian Trade Representative in Denmark, then - the deputy chairman of the board of MosExibank. After the default, the bank was liquidated, and his father went to work in the Ministry of Education of the Russian Federation. In a word, Dmitry comes from "gilded youth."
After school, he followed in the footsteps of his father - he entered MGIMO. But he became interested in the expansion of consciousness and received not only chemical, but also metaphysical poisoning. The meditating in 2008 in Altai Enteo even flashed through the central TV. In the end, the family dealt with him quite cool: Dmitry went to serve in the army. On his VKontakte page it was written: "The Airborne Forces of the Omsk Region Svetly, 2008-2009."
In 2010, he returned and began life in Moscow "from scratch." The father by that time opened the company "Herzel Pharm", selling cosmetics, for his son established another trading organization - "Portzelin Project". Dmitry recovered at a university where his father worked as a senior teacher.
They were supposed to project the image of the Hebrew God Molokh to the building of the Ministry of Health, but did not find a projector
At the same time, the young man got into the missionary society to the "Sysoevites", in the temple on Kantemirovskaya - they were engaged in a difficult business of Christian sermons among Muslims and believers in other gods. Archpriest Oleg Stenyaev blessed Enteo for a mission to "rehabilitation of the victims of the Eastern cults" and the creation of the Enlightenment.ru website. Until May 2012, Dmitry led a rather peaceful life among texts and video certificates. His random associates from a later time claim that then he even married a wealthy girl who saved from some sect.
- Where does the "will" have a means from? You write that Enteo lived on the maintenance of his wife.
Kirill Krivosheev: I don’t know what he lives now, then he told me that he lives with his wife's money. I know that they met while still in the real eastern sect. I cannot call him a wealthy person. Honestly, I cannot call none of the "God's will" wealthy people. Their shares were often broken precisely because of the lack of props. For example, I wrote about the “Moloch” operation, which was supposed to happen: they had to project the image of the Hebrew God Moloch to the Ministry of Health, but did not find a car, did not find a projector. Dima asked me for a thousand rubles on some of the gatherings. I remember he said that something needs to be done for some Moscow city deputy, he promised some money. Some money, he said, comes from some department of the Russian Orthodox Church. People who produce the content of "God's will" fill the site, receive money for it. Of course, I did not tell him that I am a journalist, but somehow suggested: "Dima, I have experience in writing texts, do you need a website, for example, a writing person?" He said: "Yes, cool, if anything, maybe we will pay something." Video engineers, photographers, of course, falls, but it is also very little money.
Dima told us: “But they told me that at a meeting in the Synod, the Patriarch said that he was very appreciated by“ God's will. ”
I am interested in something else: where did Dima get such a wide base of journalists? One of the events devoted to the abortion took place in the building of the Center for Slavic Writing and Culture, and Dima threw me two large bases, there are really a thousand contacts of journalists of all - Russian, foreign, pro -government, opposition. And I saw that it works. Remember, there was an election program of Navalny, and Navalny in one of his performances, it seems, said that he was allowing a gay parade in Moscow. And we went to the office of Alexei Navalny, put a cube there. Navalny himself put a cube, and we put a cube on the contrary, where Navalny was depicted in the form that he was from the devil, supports soda, Gomorrah, and so on. A bunch of journalists came to this event - it was Enteveshniki, it was a German channel, it was a French channel, and they took comments from Dima. That is, everything was planned in advance. They met us in the lane, were already with cameras, everything was ready.
On the rally in the "Manege" there were a young man and a girl. Pavel, who holds the camera, is quite a long -standing member of the "God's will", a Sysoa, that is, he went to the missionary school named after Father Daniil Sysoev. Pavel participated in shares in which I also participated, we are in the NTV channel video: for example, they shot the plot about our picket of Navalny's office. Pavel also wants to be a mediator, like Dima, but yet he did not succeed. Although such an interesting detail: when it was July-August, warm time in Moscow, he always walked in a camouflage jacket. I say: "Pasha, why? Now it's hot, everyone in T -shirts walk, and you are in a jacket." He says: "I once lit up, the journalists took me a picture in the jacket, and now I observe the media -image, I have to remember this." In general, there is no boyarsky without a hat.
-Many say that the shares of "God's will" are the same contemporary art as the shares of Avdeya Ter-Ogaganya or Pussy Riot, only with another sign. Can I agree with this?
Anna Brazhkina: I have the impression that Entoo met the Russian “contemporary art” back in 2010, and not only thanks to the then all the activist Internet youth to the campaigns of the “war” group.
On Seliger, he participated in the organization of the costume action "The Second Coming of Christ"
His longtime friend and permanent partner in the early actions, Andrei Kaplin, was an activist of the Prochrevsky movement "Our", a permanent participant in the Orthodox shifts of the Seliger youth camp, which Boris Yakemenko organized and where Daniil Sysoev read the young "street sermons". "Sysoevites" with the "nurses" were friends tightly. Enteo went with Kaplin to Seliger in 2010, participated there in the organization of the costume action "Second Coming of Christ" and the seminar "Mission Technology". In the same month, a gigantic artforn took place on Seliger-with one and a half thousand listeners and “best experts”, among whom were famous figures of Council-Anatoly Osmolovsky, Kirill Shamanov, Oleg Dow, Sergey Bugaev-Africa. Artists gave lectures and held master classes. Among the partners of this forum were centers of contemporary art: the Moscow Vincavod, St. Petersburg Erarta, while the St. Petersburg Loft Project "Floors". The curators of these centers selected the work of young Seliger artists to show at their sites. In general, a number of current frantic “patriots” dates back to the secret party-for example, the Glavplakat art group, making giant banners, branding the “fifth column”, and even the author of the notorious monument to St. Vladimir.
One way or another, Enteo, of course, was heard about the Council of Enteo. And when he hit, along with other "Orthodox activists", to the Tagan and Hamovnic ships, where the Pussy Riot case was obvious, the creative spirit of protest youth obviously carried him away. Soon he began to make his own "promotions".
Андрей Кураев сообщил миролюбиво, что "каждая конфессия имеет право на своих придурков"
Есть множество подтверждений того, что он мнил себя "художником-акционистом" а-ля Pussy Riot, когда "расширял пространство борьбы" и "радикализировал методы послания" с помощью "вторжения в социальную среду" путем легкого рукоприкладства. Его артистическое рвение скоро оценили и сами художники: в октябре 2012-го один из ключевых авторов московского концептуализма Константин Звездочетов и герой московского акционизма первой волны Дмитрий Пименов решили провести с Энтео совместную выставку радикального православного искусства и раструбили об этом по всему миру. Инициатор проекта, интересный неуравновешенный художник Пименов, называл Энтео "иконой стиля" православного акционизма и утверждал, что ресурсами выставку обеспечит Синодальный отдел по делам молодежи (епископ Игнатий Пунин).
В этот период о "Божьей воле" ласкательно отзываются митрополит Илларион (Алфеев), протоиерей Александр Пелин (член общественной палаты РФ), игумен Виталий Уткин, и даже Андрей Кураев сообщает миролюбиво, что "каждая конфессия имеет право на своих придурков". Обещанная выставка по необъявленным причинам не состоялась. Но из-за обоюдного публичного "экспертного признания" – как церковью, так и худсообществом – Энтео стал популярнейшей персоной в прессе и на ТВ. При этом он продолжал с завидной регулярностью совершать мелкие хулиганские нападения на людей и культурные площадки. И выдвигать собственные маниакальные цензурные требования. Которые, при ближайшем рассмотрении, слабо согласовывались с конвенциональными установками как художественного, так и церковного сообщества.
Вероятно, именно в этой игре Энтео "на два фронта" и кроется разгадка того странного факта, что после недавнего "захвата" одной из главных выставочных площадок страны – Манежа – его открыто не поддерживает ни одна из сторон, и в то же время "лидеры мнений" относятся к нему весьма мягко. Никто не просит для Энтео "двушечку", говорят дружно о "большом штрафе". Даже г-н Невзоров, этот яростный атеист всея Руси, обещался внести за Энтео необходимый залог в случае его ареста.
– Сам Энтео воспринимает себя как проповедника?
Кирилл Кривошеев: Да, он воспринимает себя как проповедника. Ему неоднократно предлагали рукоположиться, но он от этого отказывается, утверждая, что у священников мало времени остается на общественную деятельность, у них много времени на службу, на требы, на прочее, нет времени работать в медиасреде. А работать в медиасреде Диме очень нравится, он это умеет. Он говорит: нет, мне лучше быть классическим активистом. Он против всего, что противоречит классическим канонам православия: против геев, против абортов, против порнографии. Не думайте, что он какой-то купленный человек. Несмотря на то, что он питается какими-то деньгами, которые ему перепадают от спонсоров и прочее, он действительно соблюдает пост, действительно не употребляет матерных слов. Когда мы шли по переходу метро и встретили мужчину, который раздает журнал "Флирт", он остановился, стал читать ему проповедь, говорил, что вы будете за это отвечать перед Господом, найдите другую работу. Но драки не было. При мне, честно скажу, драк не было. Я знаю, что Дима горячий человек и может ввязаться в какую-нибудь потасовку, но не было.
– Почему Энтео всегда удается выходить сухим из воды, и его не тронули даже после акции в Манеже, где пострадала государственная собственность?
Кое-какую "крышу" в Москве для своих хулиганов Затулин может обеспечить и сейчас
Анна Бражкина: Очень надеюсь, что после акции в Манеже его таки "тронут". Тем не менее назову нескольких известных по открытым источникам покровителей и благодетелей Энтео. На первых порах, почти весь 2012 год, Энтео действовал "под крышей" Кирилла Фролова, главного в мире православного активиста, одержимого проповедника идеи "симфонии церкви и государства", т. е. Патриарха и Путина. Фролов с давних пор находится на содержании Константина Затулина, был и остается главой отделения "Украина" в затулинском "Институте стран СНГ".
Затулин был депутатом трех созывов ГД и ближайшим партнером мэра Лужкова по "разруливанию уличной политики" в Москве и созданию промосковского общественного лобби в Украине, Азербайджане и Молдавии. Накануне и после бегства Лужкова в сентябре 2010-го, Кремль начал "зачистку" политического поля от его ближайших соратников – собственно Затулина, Георгия Бооса, Олега Митволя, Ирины Рабер и т. д. Затулин после ряда показательных унижений (лишение поста зампреда важного комитете в ГД, невключение безо всяких объяснений в избирательные списки ЕР) проявлял невероятные чудеса чинопочитания в период выборов 2011-12, его вернули в большую политику на маленькую должность, и он сумел-таки на ней выслужиться: 1 августа 2012-го Затулин был введен в президентский Совет по делам казачества, а в апреле 2014-го Путин наградил его медалью "За освобождение Севастополя и Крыма".
Я не имею неопровержимых доказательств, но думаю, что именно казаки "по линии Затулина" в 2012–13 блокировали выставку "Духовная брань" в Москве, устраивали непотребства вокруг спектакля по Набокову в Петербурге, нападали на Гельмана в Краснодаре и на Pussy Riot в Сочи и т. п. Это его почерк, его интересы, его конфигурация друзей и врагов. Сколько и чего перепадало от Затулина через Фролова другим "православным активистам", в частности Энтео, – бог весть. Но кое-какую "крышу" в Москве для своих хулиганов Затулин может обеспечить и сейчас: "реестровое" (президентское) казачество имеет самые тесные контакты с силовиками, от МВД до МО.
Однако в какой-то момент Энтео с Фроловым демонстративно порвал, и даже угрожал ему "настоящим мужским разговором" за россказни о том, что он переметнулся к либералам. Именно в этот момент Энтео действительно пошел на сближение с художественным сообществом, о чем упоминалось выше.
Другой открытый покровитель Энтео – протоиерей Всеволод Чаплин; сеть полна их парными изображениями в торжественной обстановке. Однажды Энтео оказал протоиерею выразительную услугу – порядком избил Дмитрия Давыдова, бывшего пресс-секретаря Чаплина, выступившего в "Новой" с резкой критикой церковных порядков. И ничего Энтео за это не было.
Именно по инициативе Чаплина в 2014-м был создан сайт "Православный взгляд", главным редактором которого является Энтео. Чаплин Дмитрия за сайт хвалил. В 2015-м Энтео, под благотоворным влиянием протоиерея, почти утихимирился, сосредоточился на серьезной информационной деятельности и прекратил называть себя художником-акционистом.
Духовником же движения "Божья воля" называют игумена Виталия Уткина, руководителя Ивано-Вознесенского епархиального отдела по взаимоотношениям Церкви и общества. Вокруг Уткина сегодня постепенно формируется "антикоммунистический" центр в РПЦ, проповедующий равенство коммунизма и фашизма – в пользу монархии.
– А что он сам говорит о политике и контактах с политиками?
Кирилл Кривошеев: Я как-то вывел на разговор: а что ты будешь делать, если наше правительство пойдет на уступки геям, грубо говоря, будут разрешены гей-парады, гей-браки? Он сказал, что в таком случае он готов будет взять в руки оружие. То есть я считаю, что его даже нельзя назвать сильно проправительственным человеком, потому что вы можете найти его высказывания как в пользу каких-то решений действующей российской власти, так и против нее. Помню, спрашивал Диму о контактах с политиками. И он говорил, что приходилось общаться с Милоновым, например. Но это максимум. Политики уровня повыше (та же Елена Борисовна Мизулина) никогда такого радикала не поддержат. Дима жаловался на это. Мол, что ж они боятся?
На выборах мэра Москвы Дима поддержал вовсе не Собянина. Собянин был недостаточно православным. Насколько я помню, это был Левичев. Левичев говорил о том, что он православный и поддерживал строительство храмов. А в Думу Диме организовали пропуск вовсе не единороссы, а ЛДПРовцы.
Они должны осознавать, что они – разменная монета. Нужны для драк
Если мы с вами вообразим, что на выборах президента в 2018-м будет кандидат, который пообещает вернуть статью за гомосексуализм, запретить аборты, построить храм в каждом населенном пункте, ввести обязательное ЕГЭ по основам православия, брать на государственные должности только воцерковленных людей, ввести обязательный налог для бизнеса на строительство храмов, то Дима поддержит его. Я бы сравнил "Божью волю" с "Правым сектором". Велика ли разница между националистом, радикальным религиозным активистом и футбольным фанатом? Главное – идея. Если ты не русский/не православный/не за "Спартак" – я буду тебя бить. Такие люди – движущая сила революции. Но они должны осознавать, что они – разменная монета. Нужны для драк. Когда власть взята – их вытурят, и придут люди с деньгами.