On November 29, at a press conference in the Memorial human rights center, lawyers and the father of the murdered Hasanguseynov brothers told how it was possible to turn the course of the investigation. On November 15, the Investigative Committee of the Investigative Committee of the RD after 1.5 years opened a criminal case on the murder of Nabi and Hasanguseyn, and the case on the fact of an encroachment on the life of law enforcement officials was terminated. The reason is phenomenal: on this day in the area of Horde-Back, 2 km from the village of Hindy Shamilsky district, there was no special operation and there were no representatives of the power structures of the encroachment.

On November 13, Murtazali Gasanguseynov was announced about this father of the dead by the deputy head of the Office for the Supervision of the investigation, inquiry and operational-search activities of the prosecutor's office of the Republic of Dagestan A. Bagomedov . At the same time, the official answer states that the basis for initiating the first criminal case under Art. 317 of the Criminal Code was inaccurate information and. O. Head of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia in the Shamilsky district of Ibrahim Aliyev.

Recall that in the official summary of the Ministry of Internal Affairs in Dagestan, compiled and signed by Aliyev, it was reported that “on August 23, 2016, about 21 hours, 25 min., Employees of the SOG-5 of the Federal Security Service of the Russian Federation, the CPE of the Ministry of Internal Affairs with the village of Gergibil, the FSB of Russia together with the Russian Ministry of Internal Affairs in the Shamilsky district during the operational and vitality The unidentified persons fired on the implementation of operational information shots from automatic weapons on law enforcement officials and were killed by return fire. ”

In the new criminal case, on the fact of the murder of Nabi and Hasanguseyn , unidentified persons with unidentified weapons that shot at them are again appeared.

The lawyer of the PC "Memorial" Murad Magomedov noted that Murtazali Hasanguseynov was already interrogated in the status of the victim. The basis of excitement was the report on the discovery of signs of a crime. “It is not clear only what to do with his father’s statement of January 31, 2017, which he submitted to the Investigative Committee. There is still no answer to him, despite the decision of the Soviet District Court, which recognized the inaction of the head of the Investigative Committee of the Investigative Committee of the Republic of Dagestan. The fact that it was planned to terminate the case under Art. 317 and excitement under Art. 105, it was known several months ago during the reception of the deputy head of the Investigative Committee of the Investigative Committee for RD. But until the last, the new investigator Eric Rajabov could not confirm this information to us. There is still no official termination resolution. I don’t know why it is so secret, apparently there are moments that they do not want to advertise now. I have no illusions about the new criminal case, because until the last, the deputy prosecutor of the Republic of Dagestan Sergei Belyakov tried to appeal the decision of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Dagestan in the cassation instance, ” the lawyer explained.

According to him, if the journalists had not covered this topic, nothing would have moved away. “Investigators wanted to terminate the criminal case even earlier in connection with the death of the suspects, but there is a decision of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation, which states that if a relative is against the termination, then he should be completed and transferred to the court. Naturally, in this form the materials cannot be transferred to the court, and the terms of the investigation are coming to an end, since almost 1.5 years have passed, and there is no reason to extend it. Thus, the law enforcement system has driven itself into a dead end, ” added Murad Magomedov. It is possible that the complaint of Hasanguseynov Sr. in the European Court of Human Rights also influenced the initiation of a criminal case.

Police Head

The head of the human rights organization Law and Law and the representative of the initiative group of four villages of the Shamilsky district, Jambulat Gasanov , commenting on the resolution, which refers to unidentified persons who killed Nabi and Hasanguseyn, said that everyone knows that these were security forces.

“From which exactly they are units, we cannot say. But witnesses confirm that they saw them on this day. Two know by name, others learned by faces. They are employees of the police department of the Shamilsky district.

We are talking about employees who spent the night in the murder in the murder. At the time of discovery of corpses, they were not guarded by anyone. Literally half an hour later, as our fellow villager, Israpil Magomedov found bodies, a group of employees of 19 people with stretchers appeared. If they did not know about this, where did they get this information from? " - Hasanov was perplexed.

Earlier it was reported that people saw how several “Urals” entered the village with riot police. In addition, a few hours before the murder in the pasture, the guys had a district shamil Gamzatov . According to him, Ibrahim Aliyev sent him there to find out where the guys are, while he called from their phone. Most likely, then to track the movement of the Hasanguseynovs on billing. After this incident, the district police officer quit, but a year later he returned to work again.

Ibrahim Aliyev before the murder of the shepherds was with the prefix “and. O. ”, after they established himself in office. And continues to lead the police department.

When Murtazali Hasanguseynov heard Aliyev’s surname, he could not restrain himself: “My sons were killed intentionally. I assume that the police chief could be a possible customer of the murder. Maybe he called employees from the CPE, where he used to work, and two employees of the police department in the Shamilsky district. Two shepherds were killed, and a month later he was approved as a boss. Our children were worthy of their village, Dagestan, people, country, and we want to return their pure names. I want to ensure that those involved in the murder of my children are punished. Between the two Ziyrats (sacred place) they killed, such people have something sacred? ”

Gasanguseynov and Gasanov believe that Aliyev acted on the direction from above - when it was necessary to find the guilty in the murder of the judge, which occurred on August 11. “As we know, the killers of the judges found earlier, but the militants receded. The uncle told them ... They decided to write off the Gasanguseynov brothers, since the parents were sick, the village was small, small, there is no one behind. Then, after the order of the President of the Russian Federation, to find the killers before the end of the year, these militants were still found and killed at the end of December 2016, ” they added.

Dzhambulat Hasanov also told how they were originally hindered in the investigation. According to him, first, through the deputy administration of the district, the lawyer Said Ibragimov , who did nothing, interfered in every way, interfered with the money for 8 months and did not return the money, and when they decided to contact the Memorial human rights center, tried to intimidate and accused the center’s lawyers of protecting extremists. ] § [

Summary of the excuse of the murder