Translated material
Sorry to Sobchak
In Russian political life, a large event - a registered presidential candidate made a squabble with the chief of staff of the unregistered.
But let's start with the background. A few days ago there were reports that Ksenia Sobchak flew to Bali to hold a corporate party there.
Like a person who has surrounded the whole Magadan and Barvikh, I cannot stay away from this beautiful story. Sobchak in the midst of a signature campaign went to Bali for a corporate party. Together with her, Ivanushki, Semenovich, Kamedi-Clab, cords and collective Katya Lel Pic.twitter.com/07RNI1G5I6
- George Alburov (@alburov) January 11, 2018
Ksenia Sobchak conducts 🔥 hot negotiations on the fundraising (no). In fact, she conducts a corporate party for billionaire Alexander Roslyakov instead of collecting signatures for her nomination to presidents. This is not our candidate. pic.twitter.com/xarroutojb
- Protest Moscow (@nedimon_MSK) January 11, 2018
And the customer of the event is Alexander Roslyakov, he is the contractor of Gazprom Pic.twitter.com/jvxvllzpa6
- George Alburov (@alburov) January 11, 2018
Ksenia Sobchak, who went to Grudinina for rest in Germany, visited Bali this week. Clearly, inherently.
- La Russie Parle (@russia_calls) January 11, 2018
On the other hand, what's wrong with the fact that Sobchak had a corporate party in Bali? She didn’t go there for taxpayers money?
- Fields behind the hill (@lndcalling) January 11, 2018
It is also important about Sobchak: she, as a true nomenclature, collects money not from below, from citizens, but at the top, from some muddy sponsors (but most likely she does not collect at all, but has long received from Pyni)
- Mars (@mars_fm13) January 15, 2018
To be honest, I do not see a big problem that Sobchak went to Bali. Well, yes, it is not good for collectors. But after all, the claim to Sobchak should not be in the quality of its campaign, but to the very existence of this campaign
- Anna Vellikok (@annavellikok) January 15, 2018
The main problem of presidential candidates both admitted to participation and registration is not - this is financial unscrupulousness.
This also applies to Navalny with his criminal cases of an economic nature. And Volkova with PVG activities. The question is there are there any double standards? Why do many steal and much more than Navalny and “everything gets away with them?” Of course, there are such. There are those who, for example, stole less, but really, unlike Navalny Selo. And those who stole more, but there are no complaints about justice to them.
And of course, unlike Navalny, most of these crooks, as they are larger and less, do not have political presidential ambitions. Does this pursue Navalny political? No. Politically motivated? Yes. But is the politically motivated persecution of the economic crimes of Navalny, the most Navalny to an honest person? Of course not.
This also applies to the economic non -literacy of Grudinin. Many liked the fact that Grudinin went instead of Zyuganov. Someone did not like the fact that Grudinin was not resting in Russia. But the fact that the decision to nominate Grudinin from the Communist Party was made at the last moment and he:
A. did not have time to clean his accounts in the EU
B. did not have time to cover offshore schemes in Liechtenstein.
V. understands that he will not win and does not want to curl up all the combinations that work for many years.
This does not justify him. Didn't you have time to prepare? They will beat you on this. Not ready and you think that there is a campaign for your discredit? Well, yes, she goes. There are no questions. But the texture, you gave it yourself.
Against this background, the claim of Volkov to Sobchak about Bali is unrealistically funny. Everyone knows that Sobchak is leading corporate parties. Everyone knows that in many corporate parties she accepts the nal. Something from Nala does not declare. <work> Of course, the severity of her guilt. Actually, all claims to Sobchak now are claims like a competitive opposition to it for the future. Demonstrating that they are afraid of her for the future. And no power. And Navalny. For whom Sobchak turned out to be much worse than Putin. Because Navalny is free. And Sobchak can take a protest electorate from him.
Ksenia Anatolyevna herself denied everything.
But she did not convince critics.
“How tired of the stuffing of ill-wishers, envious people and competitors!” Said Ksenia Sobchak. Take an hour ago. Bali. https://t.co/cigij7be0w pic.twitter.com/unrqlna6bt
- Ruslan shaveddinov (@shavedDinov) January 11, 2018
You can’t lie in 2018 so brazenly. You cannot falsify geotags. You can not fly in two hours from Bali to Domodedovo. You cannot call yourself a presidential candidate if there is no election. You can not participate in a lie and multiply a lie. pic.twitter.com/lcut1jdbnw
- Leonid Volkov (@leonidvolkov) January 11, 2018
Then Sobchak decided to demand personal apologies, and she introduced herself as a convenient case: her broadcast on Echo of Moscow ended shortly before Leonid Volkov’s broadcast, and she went to his studio.
All Sobchak was lowered to Volkova
- Rospoblknadzor (@ovciom) January 16, 2018
Some of the candidate's behavior caused approval, if not applause.
Ahahahaha, live the echo of Moscow Sobchak reports Feikomet Volkov))) It is great to see how the crook fidgets and mutters in response something about the Kremlin. Well, yes, the on -duty excuse) pic.twitter.com/mjhbl8hez1
- Ilya Craft (@iremeslo) January 15, 2018
- You are a quilted jacket! - No, you are a quilted jacket! You listened to a summary of Volkov’s election debates and Sobchak in the studio "Echo of Moscow"
- V /// DY ™ (@subb_zer0) January 15, 2018
Leonid Volkov, of course, is an enchanting butter.
- Vasily Utkin (@radioutkin) January 15, 2018
Sobchak, who played the noble altruism "for Navalny", looked pretty funny, but the wolves that really offended at it look like always ugly.
- Philip Maslovsky (@soulstray) January 15, 2018
The chief ally of Navalny, Comrade Volkov, sobbed K. Sobchak from scratch. In general, it resembles one Irkutsk history. I do not exclude that the clinical tendency to meaningless lies is some kind of tribal feature of the bosses. Sobchul, being at Echo MSC, learning that Volkov was in the next studio, burst there (directly on the air) and arranged a liar there a great drain. Well done, Ksyukha! Keep it up!
Ksenia Anatolyevna, you are beautiful.
God, God, I also want so much calm and self -confidence.
With pleasure, I looked like a viper that is the most toad on the air of the Echo of Moscow. This is me about the conversation between Sobchak and Volkov. Navalnenok, of course, screwed up expertly.
Sobchak is powerful, of course. I’m a weak person, when I lie about me, I just don’t react. And Ksyukha all the time lives in a reality show. Well this is what nerves you need to have.
But on the other hand, all this is some kind of kindergarten. This is before us a presidential candidate and the head of the headquarters of the person who also wanted to be a presidential candidate.
Well, for whom, after watching all this, we will go to vote?
PS Separately, of course, I can’t help but note the next and, this time, the obvious proof of many times repeated thesis that I have been lying and wolves to lie, lie, and never apologize for the lies.
Very interesting: the conditional half about this video says that Volkov is well done, and the other conditional half, that Sobchak is well done.
I’m not sure that someone in this video is generally well done, but purely emotionally, behaviorally, Sobchak looks stronger (although I don’t know who is really right with this corporate party).
But those to whom Sobchak is not like, much more.
I turned on the Echo to see the air Volkov. Directly, Sobchak comes in direct broadcast, accompanied by two goblins with cameras. Povy in the face, remove the screen. The air goes. Leading in shock. You can take out a girl from home-2, you can not withdraw the house-2 from the girl. https://t.co/7iostu9qrh
- Alexey Navalny (@navalny) January 15, 2018
Imagine, Sobchak at the next meeting jumps to Putin with two goblins and begins to ask why his son -in -law is the youngest billionaire of Russia or about Roldugin? Funny, yes https://t.co/rzxmzdcwzj
- George Alburov (@alburov) January 15, 2018
And remember how Ksenia Sobchak ran out with the operators on the stage during Putin’s press conference and demanded the truth from him? And I don't.
- Shilo in the wall (@michaelnacke) January 16, 2018
If Sobchak needed apologies, and not a show on cameras and scandals to promote her campaign, she could demand an apology and waited Volkov in the corridor. Poking cameras in a laptop with private correspondence is low and shameful.
- Sable Love (@sobollubov) January 16, 2018
Sobchak needs to transfer the agenda from the illegitimacy of Putin's candidate to the squabble with Navalny. Instead of a boycott - heating interest in a scam. https://t.co/w7wx1d8jpz
- Thoughts of the perzient (@vvp2_0) January 16, 2018
Will the debate Sobchak and Zhirinovsky be?
- Pani Walewska (@pani_walewska) January 16, 2018
Even if the wolves were completely wrong, and Sobchak did not conduct a corporate party in Bali, but held a matinee in an orphanage in Murmansk, then she did not attract a single supporter with her behavior, but pushed away many.
- Joseph Schweik (@jozef_schweik) January 15, 2018
I dreamed: I open the toilet, and there Sobchak with the camera sits on the toilet and asks me: why did you retweet Volkova that I went to Bali? Come on a refutation and toilet paper immediately.
- Catch up! E7y09 (@mix_voronezh) January 16, 2018
Sobchak claims that this video where she is taking an event in Bali does not exist. Retweet him, please, so that she finally notices him https://t.co/ny1zc5eids
- vladislav (@unkn0wnerror) January 15, 2018
I want to speak out on two questions: 1) the headquarters of Navalny really really wet the CS for flights2) How did the CS want to get at least some answer from Volkov, if I did not give him a word? Volkov in the full video looks calmer and better
- Nuclear dance (@polinanem) January 16, 2018
TOP-5 Otmazkok Sobchak: 1. I did not promise to cancel corporate parties2. I promised, but I have not been registered yet3. Registered, but this is a meeting with an investor4. There was no meeting, I did not fly anywhere5. L. Volkov villain, let him apologize
- Alexey Shigurov (@dor_mazafaka) January 16, 2018
I would like to note Beata Bubenets, who participated in the incident between Sobchak and Volkov - climbing in his face and laptop with a camera. Just another additional touch to the portrait.
- Mitya Aleshkovsky (@Aleshru) January 15, 2018
Interesting experience: what happens if you cross Life-2, House-2, and also Ramzan Akhmatovich Kadyrov.
What happened.
During the day they call from the echo and suddenly invite in the evening to the "flight of flight"; Usually they call in advance, but anything happens. I come, sit in the guest, and I hear - that Ksenia Sobchak is on the air, it ends the broadcast, and I, respectively, will begin after the news.
I specifically left the guest and went to the “small” studio (Ksenia had an interview with a “big”) so as not to create uncomfortable situations, and even in order to prepare for the broadcast-since the invitation is day-day, and the format for me was new, it was necessary to understand at least what kind of transfer it was.
In Ksenia, the ether ends at 20.59, it starts at 21.03, in the interval of news. I sit, Ksenia bursts, with her two cameras and someone else; cameras in my face. Ksenia shouts: Leonid, you must apologize, you lied that I led a corporate party at Bali, all that. (We must still notice that I didn’t say anything about the corporate party - it’s easy to verify; it was the information of the “protest Moscow”, but I really wrote that the trip to Bali looks strange, and all the more it looks strange that at the same time she uploading pictures from Domodedovo, and people at that time cut her from the beach party; so it is impossible). I get up-uncomfortable and wrong when she hangs over me, and try to politely and calmly explain that I have nothing to apologize for, and that, in any case, the studio where the broadcast is about to begin-well, this is not the most suitable place to clarify the relationship.
Here the host comes in, sits down, begins to read the news. I also sit down: firstly, at that moment there should be silence in the studio, and secondly-well, it’s just impolite, the presenter works. And all that I could say, I told her. But ... she does not leave! He continues to loudly and brazenly “demand apologies” (I still did not understand, for what), one of her cameras removes Ksenia herself, the other climbs into my laptop monitor (I have some notes before the ether). Well, that is, it is not even life, but worse. Then I honestly taken aback: well, I can’t push her out of the studio! I try to choose words and somehow calmly discuss what is so simply impossible.
At this time, the news ends (poor presenter, I am very ashamed of him for all this shameful booth), and my broadcast begins. The presenters do not really understand what to do: they represent me, they begin to ask questions, and Ksenia does not go with their cameras. Dumb scene; Everyone is ashamed. In addition to one presidential candidate.
Finally, she unfolds to her cell, proudly reads a notation and edification for me and leaves.
And then it turned out to be an excellent "flight analysis"; Thanks to the "echo" for being invited.
I watched the video Sobchak with Volkov. To her deep dissatisfaction is forced to notify the public that Leonid Volkov looks like a bunny on a video. Even a pretty bunny. (But I hope it will make it from this assessment and this fact will smooth out my torment)
As for Ksenia Sobchak, echoing with his Shapito, so listen, they promised you from the Kremlin that the elections would be a holiday. And so.
And what a holiday without Zhirinovsky. But Zhirinovsky is out of the very indecent many, they found Sobchak.
Have you thought a holiday is just a fair with pies and buffoons? Nothing of the kind. This is also house-2 in every house, sorry for the pun.
But in general, things with the turnout are quite bad, it seems that if the “serious political journalist Sobchak”, which has been asking Putin’s “sharp” questions at the conference for a year now (but never losing access to the conference, due to the unprecedented acuteness of issues, is obvious), recalls the good old Life News and, grabbing a couple of standard buffashes, is going to bomb Echo.
So the NTV channel once raised the ratings, so now the presidential candidate raises the turnout.
The next stage, I think, is a hidden video of something like that. Kim Kardashian, by the way, became famous.
To what a disgusting person citizen C (it is amazing that there are those who still like this behavior, judging by the tape, the frank marginalization of some is simply evident)
Here I look at the election campaign of Ksenia Sobchak and I think this is about.
What gigantic value still has a reputation!
If you want to be taken seriously if you want to do some serious career of politics and public figure, you can’t spoil your biography with work in "House-2", etc. projects. Never. At all. For you can get dirty quickly, but you will never be able to wash yourself. If you were at least seven spans in the forehead and a light of common sense.
Yesterday's trick in the studio "Echo" only emphasizes my innocence. "Dom-2", comrades, is a great power. You can’t approach this. For he will pursue you forever.
You read the disputes around the phenomenon of Sobchak to the people on Echo - as if I got into the older group of kindergarten. "He was the first to start." What kind of threshold of disgust still you must still have. Are you offended by unverified information about yourself? What could be easier than on its own channels to refute it - the good at hand of the candidate not only instagram with a telegram, but also federal channels. To come for an apology with the camera, which also dulls in the monitor with another person is an abomination. This is the habalism of the highest sample. Kadyrovschina Light. Such "all means are good." The only bad thing is that this cannot be explained. Yes, and there are things that do not need to be explained at all - they must be known from infancy. And by the way, if the word “gopnik” has a female family?
Well, we must pay tribute - Volkov first got up and talked, and fell silent only when the news began (as well as he pronounces the word "Judenrat").
It is amazing how Ksenia Sobchak touched the story about Bali. Very painful point. I can imagine how we are Tanya Felgenhauer everywhere for Russia-24 employees with operators and personally Vladimir Rudolfovich, and hysterically, we need to apologize for the fact that they thought about us about us. Not on Facebooks, but on the air of federal television and radio.
Well, on the other hand, we never led the house-2.
And where did the video come from from the party, which Sobchak allegedly led? Is it obtained by the wrong methods of Lifenews (removed hiddenly, from under the floor, from afar, and even nothing is visible) that Volkov despises so?
- Nikita Likhachev (@niketas) January 15, 2018
There were no “two cameras”, as Leonid Volkov writes or even more so “two goblins with cameras”, as Alexei Navalny wrote. No stand on our part too. She shot Ksenia (in an episode with Volkov) from our team only Beata Bubenets, who does this every day for the project candidate.doc. All the rest of the fiction.
Volkov, I must say, was well held by fellow under the pressure of Sobchak (although, I must say, he behaves almost always, at any meetings - he sits and threshes something in the keys in his laptop, that is, the skill has been developed).
True, the Volkov himself is not without sin: the Kremlin video bloggers “wool” the video in which he “opens the headquarters of Navalny in Sochi” ... Through the projector’s screen, while in Cyprus he himself (in the frame, even a characteristic hotel ring is on his hand; these rings “mark” their guests - they are allowed to be on the beach and into the dining room).
In general, the topic "Sobchak on Bali" raised the first to Navalny himself (apparently, he takes revenge on her for an invitation to be a "trustee" in the elections). Which, as you know, is also not alien to family vacation in France.
And in the same campaign, Grudinin, who also spent New Year's holidays away from his native state farm - either in Switzerland, or in Austria (where he closed his billion bills). Хотя, по его словам, он там "отдыхал по путевке" (именно так и объяснил отлучку - дескать, купил путевку (sic!) еще до того, как узнал, что будет претендентом на президентство - не пропадать же?!)
Для человека с зарплатой в совхозе 20 млн. руб. в год (как он объяснял публике на ток-шоу после объявления о его выдвижении КПРФ) - вроде да, экономно (сколько он там потратил на "путевку" в Швейцарию - может, целый миллион?! Если со всем семейством, слугами и личным шофером?) Но если у него, как мы теперь знаем, аж 7,5 млрд. личных денег на счетах - тут уже такая экономность кажется несколько чрезмерной; отправил бы тогда личного шофера вместо себя одного - было бы как раз по-коммунистически!)
Забавно, что эти скандалы с "загранкой" - не в первый раз, все это уже было. Помнится, как раз в канун предыдущих президентских, почти "на пике протестов", в январе 2012 года, Навальный точно так же "на праздники уехал отдыхать куда-то за границу. И все тогда уехали - и Собчак с ними. Все протестанты "рассосались".
О чем эти назойливо повторяющиеся истории говорят? Если смотреть с оптимизмом - они говорят о том, что у протестного движения в стране есть немалый резерв: достаточно найти где-нибудь нового лидера протеста, который НЕ БУДЕТ каждый раз под Новый год свалить в загранку "на корпоративы",а будет в это время с особенной силой бороться с прогнившим режимом ЗДЕСЬ - сразу же степень воодушевления масс подскочит на невиданные прежде уровни!
Но, как поется в песне у Окуджавы, "но где ж его найти, ах, где ж его найти..."
А вот и некоторый итог от главного редактора радиостанции.
Я сожалею, что начало передачи с Леонидом Волковым было скомкано.
Приношу извинения тем слушателям Эха, которые сочли этот инцидент неуместным
«Эхо Москвы» готово предложить дебаты между Ксенией Собчак и Алексеем Навальным.
Эхо Москвы готово предложить дебаты между Ксенией Собчак и Алексеем Навальным. А дебаты между Путиным и Навальным - не готово
— Россия не сегодня (@Ruissa_Tuday) 15 января 2018 г.
-
Ivan Belyaev
Social Networks Editor Radio Liberty