Translated material
"Leader raved." Bloggers analyze Putin's Valdai speech
On October 27, Vladimir Putin spoke at a meeting of the Valdai discussion club. Dmitry Peskov said that this speech "will read and re -read." His words are echoed by pro -government commentators.
Putin made a completely amazing speech today. And I must say, completely not "Putin" in style. Putin made a speech worthy not so much the great ruler as the great philosopher. Putin talked about how it will be, and how humanity should develop in the next period.
In Valdai, we saw Vladimir Putin in the image of a thinner of global significance, which forms and formulates the meanings of the development of world civilization, offers exits from a dead end, into which the planet drove the Anglo -Saxon globalism and capitalism.
Peskov: Putin’s speech will study and re -read! In fact, speech is an absolute tracing paper with a dozen similar ones. But in the near future we will see a lot of mocking lyzostanism of Putin’s officials. Just approval and maintaining is not enough, you must certainly praise. pic.twitter.com/vi69c2yxku
- Sable Love (@sobollubov) October 27, 2022
It seemed to commentators from another camp that in his three-hour speech, Putin did not say anything fundamentally new: the president again spoke of the “unjust unipolar world order”, which establishes the West, that Russians and Ukrainians are “one people”, about the dangers of gay parades and the “abolition of Russian culture”.
The paradox of the heard is that nothing surprised me, because there were neither the yots of new ideas, approaches and thoughts.
All goats, and I am alone d'Artagnan - we have already heard that
As soon as I saw this self-whaled face, which with an incredible aplomb, as a revelation, tells us the beaten quotes from my past performances, I realized that the last speakers left him who could at least be found in his mouth at least something fresh and new.
All the goats, and I am alone d'Artagnan - we have already heard that a hundred times. The West colonized Ukraine, we are the only guarantor of its sovereignty, what else is there? All the same, the same thing ...
Lying, ignorance, envy, resentment, anger, fear, banality. If you want to taste a cocktail, in which there is all this - read the online broadcasts of Putin's performance on Valdai.
This is how a brief retelling of the speech of Vladimir Putin performed by the pro -government political scientist Yevgeny Mingchenko :
Short summary of Putin's performance on Valdai:
The Americans are insolent.
Europeans do not decide anything. If we correct , take, so be it to a big Eurasia.
The tracks are a fool. But no one pulls her.
Soon the dollar and Euro Kirdyk.
Handsome - independent Asian rulers of SI, Modi, Erdogan, Bin Salman and Kim.
Lula or Bolsonaru - it makes no difference.
Russia is the leader of the anti -globalists. But for the balance of interests.
Need a reform of the UN Security Council.
We cope with military and economic tasks.
I was inevitable.
Let's look at Odessa - Khusnullin will do beautifully. But they are ready for negotiations.
Zelensky - no one to call. But let him call him from Washington to agree.
In Russia, handsome Sichin, Kovalchuki, Sobyanin, Timchenko, Kiriyenko, Ramzan, Miller, Likhachev, Novak, Prokhanov, Lukyanov and Bezrukov.
At the request of Lukyanov, the Russian workers will increase the salary.
We are not in a hurry to Paradise. But in principle, they are ready.
But the retelling of the journalist Echo Ksenia Larina is much more popular on the Web:
To help schoolchildren and teachers. A brief retelling of the historical speech of VVputin at the Valdai Forum. It is recommended for discussion in the lessons "Talk about important"
Some kind of nonsense
Move your brains
Come up with something new
Look at yourself
Generally cheated
General Suleimani took and killed
What is it in general
Where we live
This is what it is
Yes, let them do what they want
We don't climb into someone else's yard
What they want and do
CAP-Tsarap and West puffed our resources
Do not build offended
Was we made a state trim?
Well, what to wait until they start?
Everyone to sit on the pope and not to grunt
We are a great, great, we are a great country!
Liz Trasses blurted out there, the girl is not in herself a little
They scolded at all
Some kind of nonsense
This is nonsense
This is what it is
This is what it is
What they want and do
The company Putin’s wit again forced many to compare the president with a taxi driver or fellow traveler from a reserved seat car.
TASS is authorized to say: sit on the pope and do not grunt! pic.twitter.com/ebi2cvd9lv
- Fedor Krasheninnikov/Fedor KraSheninnikov (@fyodorrrrr) October 27, 2022
According to his grandfather, in 2014, Yanukovych actually transferred power, but the West still arranged a coup to show who the master was in the house. “Everyone sits on the pope evenly, do not grunt,” Putin explained. The test: “Talk of a taxi driver or speech President of the Russian Federation”
- tape (@oldlentach) October 27, 2022
Peskov: Putin’s speech on Valdai “will read and re -read.” Putin: everyone sits on the pope evenly and do not grunt.
- Chronicle of degradation (@sergeenko_i) October 28, 2022
"Sitting on the pope is even and not to grunt." Again he is about the "ass". What kind of fixation he has? What happened to him in the school years?
- Uncle Shu (@shulz) October 28, 2022
Everyone does not give up to everyone on the pope and you can’t say, otherwise you won’t say - Putin. The priest does not leave the leader. Maybe because it is there that he leads his people?
- Leonid Nevzlin (@nevzlin) October 27, 2022
"Sit on the pope and not to grunt" ...
As I heard, for some reason I remembered about the Medvedev duck right away.
"F. Lukyanov: Do you associate yourself with whom you are more: with tops or with the bottoms? V. Putin: with the bottoms, of course, I am from the bottom."
- And what kind of you are:
Versh, bottoms - who are your relatives?
- I left the deepest people ...
But he did not come out of me.
Putin said that he once taxed. And I always go by taxi. He is like a mirror. Every second Russian taxi driver from the province could have performed at the Valdai club instead of him.
Putin did not look and did not listen, deciding that now he simply could no longer say anything important, new or at least terrible.
Judging by the reviews, I was not mistaken.
Everyone says that there was another Bu-boo boo of Hanygi from a reserved seat car.
Putin spoke for a long time and pointless
He contradicted himself, lied and carried complete nonsense. It was the speech of a real "gardener", an old man in the insanity, whom his grandchildren were exiled to the cottage so that he did not burn the apartment inadvertently.
Putin, in this sense, "no one grandfather", like a draw of a grandmother at Ilf and Petrov, who was afraid of electricity. He is afraid of the Internet, Ukrainians and in his ass (he mentioned it again).
But this is all not news. You can not watch and read this speech.
It turns out that there is such a palindrome:
The leader cheerfully raved proudly.
That's all I have to say ...
Old Irteniev in a new way. I hope Igor Moiseich will forgive me a free appeal in his classic ...
Here the old man urinates
A stream of words, where is Valdai
He would like to seem smart
But we - at least get into a loop!
Break a smooth current
Schizophrenic stream
Do not allow beliefs
My humanitarian.
Pass calmly past this
I am not able to, like a patriot ...
What to do, who would advise
But the people are silent again.
Many opposition commentators believe that analyzing the President’s understanding is a ungrateful thing.
I listen to Putin's report "How we have lost touch with reality" on the Valdai Forum
Of course, you should ask: is he going to engage in his country? But who to ask. The man completely left.
Putin spoke for an hour or a half with the TV
Putin spoke for an hour or a half with a TV - with some fictitious, invented American or German or Dutch TV. Has no one ever explained to Putin that to whining and talking with the TV all the time is a weak position. Especially if you do not refer to facts, but simply splash out emotions. Much of Putin said about the West is close to the Middle Eastern, Indian Chinese politicians and intellectuals. But I do not know how useful this transfer is now useful for them. They understand that there are words and are things. In fact, Russia demonstrates weakness. To everyone who can already demonstrate what a weak state and a weak army he has. Despite the fact that there are missiles, shells, bullets, poisons and everything else that is needed for the murder and torment of people
The problem is that with the Bolshevik, who had a couple of April abstracts in his head, it was much easier to deal than with Putin, who had a porridge from Solzhenitsyn with Fidel Castro in his head.
"President of the Russian Federation" is in dusk
Putin’s today's speech at the Valdai Forum once again confirms that the so -called The "President of the Russian Federation" is in dusk, it is completely disoriented and is not able to adequately evaluate what is happening. He does not understand that he mentioned Russia from scratch - this is very bad.
Putin: Confidence in his infallibility is a very dangerous state.
Golden words, our precious
Putin in 2019: We will wait until the Americans spend money on technology, and then-DAC-Tsarap
Putin in 2022: West Tsap-Tsarap - and picked our foreign currency reserves
Something went wrong (((((((((((((((((((((((((
This means that the problem is that the peoples do not want the West (UN) to lead them. I don’t understand, Putin is sent orders from the West, but he is: “I will not!”?
They to him: "Well, you end there to kill people, can you restore your car industry, it will be more useful?"
And he: "No, this is my sovereign right. We have consulted with the cannibals and decided not to listen to you."
He just does not like everything that exists now, it is a blue flame
There are a lot of experts in the Valdai club, but there is no one to explain to Vladimir Vladimirovich that the Bretton-Wood system of currency regulation ceased to exist in 1971, so in vain he was angry and wants to dismantle it. Perhaps he would even like the Bretton-Wood system, since it was based on a fixed price of gold and solid currency courses. But, probably, the experts of the Valdai club know that you can’t please Putin in this way. He simply does not like everything that exists now, it is a blue flame. Like the decadent Gippius, he wants what is not in the world. Unlike Hippius, he has an atomic bomb, and there is no Merezhkovsky pair - philosophers, with the help of which particularly strong emotions would pacify. There is a pair of Prigozhin - Kadyrov, but has, as it seems, the exact opposite effect.
But there were also bloggers who found some meaning in the stream of Putin's eloquence.
The search for the balance of strength and interests now looks more reasonable than the desire to maintain unipolarity
The resistance of the unipolar hegemony of the leading countries of the West was in a sense inevitable. If Russia loses a very risky game that has been started by it, if the hegemony is restored contrary to the mood of the participants of the current Valdai and contrary to its key topic (“World after hegemony”), the place of Russia, as the main resisting subject, will take someone else. Nobody can cancel the law that no one will ever be able to build a vertical of power either in world politics or in the global economy. Therefore, the search for a balance of strength and interests now looks more reasonable than the desire to maintain unipolarity. However, this justified resistance of hegemony does not imply obligatory bloodshed and human suffering, for which Russia is seriously responsible this year. In the end, one could “follow the Chinese path”, as we like to talk about lost opportunities during the time of perestroika in the USSR. What to do, we did not “go along the Chinese path” the second time and now we must bear responsibility for this - both President Putin and all of us, citizens of Russia ...
Many drew attention to Putin’s statement that he ordered that Shoigu warned Western politicians about the Ukrainian "provocation using a dirty bomb."
Putin admitted that he personally instructed Shoigu to call the ministers of the defense of the leading countries of the world about the Ukrainian "dirty atomic bomb". It seems that this paranoid really believes in a dirty bomb, biolaboratories, genetic weapons and other nonsense, which carries on the air.
Stalin believed that he was surrounded by enemies of the people and pests that infect collective farm cattle by foot
It was already in the history of Russia. Another paranoic, Stalin, believed that he was surrounded by enemies of the people and pests that infect the cattle with dinoschus, were trying to sell Vladivostok to the Japanese, and greatly incorrectly improper treatment. He forced the Chekists to find confirmation of his delusional suspicions. And they composed his reports and criminal cases corresponding to his paranoid picture of the world.
It seems that now the same thing. Grandfather is sick and lives in captivity of paranoid fantasies, and the Chekists, in order to maintain their posts, compose terrible stories that rationalize his painful fears. Like, everything is so, Comrade Putin, you are extremely perspicacious, the enemies want to take possession of your poop to destroy Russia, but we wake.
Conspirology, but I would not be surprised at all if it turned out that the Russian authorities simply “lost” the worked out nuclear fuel and are now trying to be so safe
The next substantiation of "his" sounded in Putin’s speech.
Explaining the reasons for the attack on Ukraine, Putin made valuable recognition. For eight years, Ukraine has built a deeply embedded defense in the Donbass. If we waited a little more, Ukraine would build the same defense along the entire border.
Thus, Putin very clearly outlined the contours of the "new world order" for which he wages the war. One of the fundamental principles of this "order" - the closest neighbors of Russia should not be able to defend themselves. Russia should be able to armed intervention at its discretion in the affairs of its closest neighbors. So far, the closest neighbors.
Putin’s “new world order” is an old Nazi “world order”
Well, yes, here the former ZIC-President Medvedev announced a few days ago once again: any state has the right to protect its interests in the territory of another state. Ducked, shelma. Not anyone. Only special. What is its feature? And then I remembered how a couple of years ago Putin spoke about the reasons for the Second World War. He saw these reasons that the flabby "bourgeois democracies" tried to "shoot a powerful, strong -willed state."
"The new world order" Putin is the order in which "powerful volitional states" dictate their will to everyone else. This order is not new. This is an old Nazi "world order". If you want to live in this order - treasure further about the immediate ceasefire and preserve your face to Putin.
In general, the “programmatic speech” clearly did not come out of this Valdai speech - but this is for the better, commentators say.
Peskov said that Putin’s performance on Valdai will read and re -read. In the "Aesopian" language, this means that the nuclear war in the coming days will not happen. They will give time to study Putin's speech. And Putin himself has not yet figured out the end with history and did not take Lenin from the mausoleum. That's when he endures, then exactly the end of the film.
But there is good news: judging by the speeches, a nuclear war for the next ten years is postponed.
In general, if anyone says "now I will make a historical speech," then obviously a person is not in himself.
Speech will become historical over time. Or will not.
[Lost] England in World War II, and Cherchal would have bellied over the speeches.
[Lost] West Cold War, and Fulton speech would be the subject of eternal jokes.
And now a person with an economy of 1.5 percent of the world goes out and reports about the historicity of his talk of the redistribution of world order.
Come on. Flag in hand.
Only then do not suffer that they laugh at you.
In general, it is worth noting that the president clearly wants to go down in history with some of his great speech. The courtiers in every possible way convince him and others, that such was “Munich speech” and should become yesterday.
It is a pity that neither the environment of the President, nor he himself understood that great things were done by great words, and not great words.
Even before our era, the Spartans answered the Macedonian king Philip to his ultimatum in the word "if ..."
And King Leonid answered King Xerxes for the proposal of “putting up weapons” and take it. ”
Why did such simple words live and am admiration?
-
Alya Ponomareva
Social Networks Editor Radio Liberty