"Zero years of imprisonment"

Judges who sent political prisoners to the zone twice as condescending to robbers and killers

From 3 to 25 years of the camps - sentences that are carried out on politically motivated criminal cases were equal to the Stalin. The compositions of the “crimes”, for which people are sentenced to such terms, are arbitrary - from speaking to the international audience to the manufacture of home -made radio, from a replica at a meeting of the Council of Deputies to normal political activities. The choice of victims is also random: a federal politician or the Vologda stoker can be persecuted. One thing is in common: they are judged and planted for actions, in which the slightest violence was absent.

At the same time, it cannot be said that the court is also harsh to those who committed violent crimes, and in general, to the acts of the general -unit. On the contrary, as in the Gulag, “criminal” had preferences compared to “political”, and now the former have more chances to get at a minimum, or even remain at all at all. We studied the sentences that the judges who sent to the political prisoner zone in the area of ​​the political prisoner in the area.

Judge Andrey Suvorov

(sentences to Navalny, Tsurkan, Wylan)

... The most loud process is, of course, the last thing against Navalny “On the creation of an extremist community”, according to which the politician received 19 years of special regime. It was considered by the judge of the Moscow City Court Andrei Suvorov , who previously judged by the espionage of the US citizen Paul Wylan (16 years in colony) and the former top manager of Inter RAO Karina Tsurkan (15 years in colony). The list of cases that were in the production of Suvorov, the sentences for which are published by the court, are most of the processes about murders, illegal turnover of weapons and fraud.

On May 15, 2023, he sentenced to a certain Ibrochimbek Kholikov, the driver of Mosgortrans, who was accused of participating in the gang, as well as several robberies and illegal storage and transportation of firearms. At the disposal of the bandits were pistols, hammers, axes, bits ...

The criminals attacked people who, as they knew reliably, transported large amounts of cash with them. Kholikov personally charged 3 episodes. For this, he received a term, much less than trying to participate in the Navalny elections, 8 years.

And here is the case of Sultanov (sentenced on December 26, 2022): murder by a group of persons by prior conspiracy from selfish motives; illegal acquisition, transportation and wearing of firearms; Using a knowingly fake passport. Sultanov is a killer, he was hired to kill a man who recently released from prison. The reason is the redistribution of influence in the market. The object was installed behind the object. According to the prosecution, Sultanov found the right people for this, and he rented an apartment in the same house as the future victim. They even went to one sports club-Don-Sport in the LCD “Scarlet Sails”. It was there that in the gym on April 12, 2021, the Sultanov fulfilled the order: “He made at least five aimed shots from this pistol from a close distance to the victim’s head and neck, causing multiple firewood damage to the head and neck with his actions with his actions with his actions with the destruction of the skull and the brain”-this In the verdict.

For this, the murder of Suvorov gave him 14 years old (according to the totality of crimes, it turned out a total of 16). Again, less than Politzek Navalny.

Judge Sergey Podopigorov

(Cara-Murze sentence)

... Vladimir Kara-Murza* to 25 years of strict regime was sentenced by the judge of the Moscow City Court Sergey Podopigorov . Its production has a lot of cases of serious and especially serious crimes. The terms for them are significant, but less than they gave politics, whose wine is composed of the texts of his public speaking abroad.

On October 5, 2021, Podopigorov sentenced the Grevtsev case, who alive burned a drunk, who was sleeping in the entrance. 16 years of colony. March 23, 2022 - the verdict of Tursunov, Tagainazarov, Allayarov and Chabborov for a series of robberies as part of a gang. Dates - from 8 to 12 years.

The fate of the robber is softer than politics.

Judge Olesya Mendeleev

(verdict Gorinov, "Seventh Studio")

... Another high -profile case - on July 8, 2022, the first real term for the "military fakes" was received by the Moscow municipal deputy Alexei Gorinov. At a meeting of the Council of Deputies, he said that the competition of children's drawings is inappropriate to hold when the RKN tells us to call it. Gorinov used another word - and received 7 years of colony from the judge of the Tver court of Moscow Olesya Mendeleeva . The very one that was considering the case of the Seventh Studio. In general, she specialized in the affairs of drunken driving, tax evasion, theft, as well as the appointment of compulsory medical measures.

March 13, 2023 Mendeleev judged the robber Agayev. He attacked a passerby, threatening a gas gun. Mendeleev appointed him 2 years conditionally. January 13, 2022 - 1.5 years measured the robber Shirshikov. He openly took a cell phone from the store and wanted to hide, but was not lucky - he came across a policeman on the street. On January 25, 2022, even less - only 10 months - received another robber, Karimov, who was jerking a bag of a passerby from his shoulder.

Judge Azamat Bikchurin

(The verdict of Lilia Chanysheva)

... June 14, 2023, the judge of the Kirovsky District Court of Ufa Azamat Bikchurin sentenced Lilia Chanyshev to 7 years and 6 months in prison for participating in the work of the Navalny headquarters (the organization was recognized as extremist and prohibited in Russia). Lilia in the last word said that a long conclusion would deprive her of the opportunity to become a mother. The process over Chanysheva was closed from the press. In the meantime, he lasted, Bikchurin received the post of chairman of the court, but continued to participate in the hearing. How did he judge the criminals before? And so.

On January 18, 2023, he appointed 8 years 6 months in prison - only a year more than Chanysheva - repeatedly convicted by Ravshan Fattakhov, who took robbery, attempted murder and arson. Drunk, he robbed a friend, and tried to kill another familiar “by burning alive with the use of combustible fluid, that is, with particular cruelty and a generally hazardous way” (quote from the sentence). He strangled the woman, but she fought back and locked herself in the bathroom. He doused the bathroom door with a rod, set fire to a lighter. The victim tried to break out of the trap - he hit the victim several times with a knife in the chest and stomach. She remained alive miraculously.

Another verdict: Rodionov, Abdullin and Nikitin beat a person and took the old iPhone from him “in the expense of the return of duty”. Two defendants received conditionally for the year; The third, previously convicted, is 1 year and 4 months of the real term.

It can be assumed that the interests of the state Judge Bikchurin puts above the interests of a private person and therefore Chanysheva’s policy makes a punishment, commensurate with the term of the failed killer. But here is another sentence - his pen. On November 2, 2022, Bikchurin sentenced to 17 thousand rubles a fine of Sergei Sakaev, who insulted and then strangled the district police officer. The 318th and 319th articles of the Criminal Code, which Sakaev was accused, belong to the section “Crimes against the Management of Management”. But there was completely without imprisonment, although this is not a plastic cup.

Judge Anna Yurova

(sentence to Kochegar Rumyantsev)

... On December 22, 2022, the judge of the Vologda City Court Anna Yurov sentenced to three years in a colony of general regime of 61-year-old Kochegar Vladimir Rumyantsev for the spread of fakes about the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation. Rumyantsev is a radio-amateur man, at home he gathered a home-made radio. Whether someone listened to him, except for Kochegar himself and vigilant operas, is unknown. For the charge, there was enough week to listen to the content by police.

In the verdict, the act is described as follows:

QUOTE
"Rumyantsev V.A. carried out a broadcast available for listening to an unlimited circle of persons, materials containing under the guise of reliable messages of knowingly false information, namely:

• On the negative actions of representatives of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation related to the maximum destruction of settlements and with causing death to all representatives of the population in the territory of military operations in Ukraine, as well as those related to causing potential harm and danger to people's lives, with an unreasonable deprivation of the life of an indefinite circle of people in Ukraine and with the prediction of people's property, the destruction of objects that do not have military importance, including the maternity hospital and the drama, as well as causing potential harm and danger to the lives of people of the city of Mariupol;

• about the negative actions related to the deprivation of the lives of unarmed people in the territory of the city of Buch;

• As well as with a missile strike at the station and with the deliberate strike of missile strikes in order to destroy not the military, civilian population of the city of Kramatorsk. ”

The evidence of guilt is simple: what was said by Rumyantsev does not comply with the statements of the Ministry of Defense.

In other cases listened to the judge Yurov, the evidence was more diverse, and the sentences were different. On February 2, 2023, she sentenced a citizen Filichev, who hit the victim with a “rose” in the face. The consequences are "unleasable disfigurement." “The sign of disfigurement of the face belongs to aesthetic concepts, is individually defined and evaluative,” writes Yurov in the verdict. And retraining the article to less severe. And the criminal case against Filichev terminates.

On November 17, 2022, she pronounces the sentence to Pervun, who robbed a woman. In the course of the hearing, the robber and the victim reconciled - the case was stopped. July 8, 2021 - a similar decision in the case of a robber Mikhin.

Judge Daria Pugacheva

(verdict Ivanov, to the author of the telegram channel "Protest MSU")

... The author of the telegram channel "Protest Moscow State University" Dmitry Ivanov was sentenced to 8.5 years in a general regime in the case of "fakes". With his posts, the activist allegedly "blew up the authority of the Russian army and caused an unlimited circle of people a sense of anxiety and anxiety." The verdict was signed by the judge of the Timiryazevsky court of Moscow Daria Pugacheva .

On June 13, 2023, she judged Sodirjon Akhmedov, the organizer of the brothel. Punishment is a fine. On February 7, 2023, she sentenced the robber Hasanzade: 4 months with serving in a colony-settlement. May 30, 2022 - to Roman Vavilov, who broke the eyelet and jaw - the year of restriction of freedom. August 18, 2022 - to the robbers Nikita Medvedev, Anton Mozymov, Vladimir Isaev. The first two received 2 years conditionally, the third - 4 months less, also conditionally.

Judge Oksana Goryunova

(verdict to Yashin*)

... oppositionist Ilya Yashin* was judged by Oksana Goryunova , a judge of the Meshchansky court of Moscow. She measured the policy of 8.5 years of colony of general regime for the distribution of “fakes” about the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation.

Here are her other sentences. On February 21, 2022, the robber Elbekov received 2.5 years of the general regime for cutting a person with a knife and taking his phone from him, acting at the same time with the accomplices (the latter hesitates the article). More sentences - and even smaller terms: 4 months for robbery to a certain Golovnev, who was conditionally strangled in the metro of police Pavlov for 2 years.

But the most amazing: November 5, 2020, Goryunova pronounces the verdict of Gneushev, who took the phone from the teenager. The crime was committed during a period when the term of the previous conditional punishment of the accused has not yet expired.

This is usually a guarantee of a trip to the zone. But already condemned by a conditionally convention to the robber, she appoints a new conditional punishment for a period ... for 0 years.

So the verdict states: “Recognize Aleksey Yuryevich Gneushev guilty of committing a crime under Part 1 of Art. 161 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, and impose him a punishment of imprisonment for a period of 00 years. The punishment of imprisonment is considered conditional with a test term for 00 years. ”

Another “zero” sentence is Selivanov, who at the Yaroslavl station hit the policeman in the face: “... a penalty of a fine of 0000 rubles.” It can be assumed that the clerks of the Meshchansky court simply lured any specifics out of the sentences, replacing the numbers with nols, but in other sentences of the Goryunova, the amount of the assigned punishment is listed. And such a moaning is a gross violation by the apparatus of the court of existing regulatory acts.

Or maybe we are dealing with miracles of justice. And it is easy to believe in such magic, since the actions completely described by the 29th article of the Constitution as an inalienable right of a citizen form the composition of a crime for which the trips to camps are distributed to the camps of the same judges from whom the robbers leave with the “convention”.

* The authorities of the Russian Federation consider it a "foreigner."