Deputies of the Pskov City Duma denied the largest investor from Europe
A paradoxical situation has developed at the Pskov bakery: an authoritative investor was found - the venture fund of the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD), ready to invest 10 million dollars in the enterprise, but there is no possibility of obtaining these funds.

The Pskov City Duma as a representative of the largest owner - the city of Pskov - did not agree to the sale of the EBRR of 24% of the shares of the enterprise from the municipal package. Meanwhile, most of the equipment of the plant developed its resource, competitors from St. Petersburg are pressing, there is no and no money for the re-equipment of production in the city budget.
The Duma decision was made by the efforts of the deputies of Nikolai Sobol, Ivan Tsetsersky, Anatoly Tikhanov and Viktor Stepanov, whose political positions of which many observers consider the political positions close to the interests of the region’s administration. The deputies, in principle, are not against the transaction, because the blocking stake is still left with the city, but ... abstained. None of the four people's deputies who blocked a positive decision presented a clear justification for his position. Even the calculations aloud the entrepreneur Anatoly Tikhanov, who arose, in his own words, “on the go”, looked sluggish.
Why did they neglected not some kind of “horns and hooves” LLC with a muddy history and unclear intentions, but a serious investor who is ready to invest 10 million dollars in the region’s economy (more than 300 million rubles, a third of the city budget)?
We asked to comment on the situation of the General Director of the Pskov Bakery OJSC Viktor Phenodnin.
Viktor Ivanovich, who owns the shares of OJSC Pskov Bakers?
The enterprise has 251 shareholders. The largest is the administration of the city of Pskov, it owns 49% of the shares. Another 48% are owned by employees of the enterprise. The remaining 3% are the so -called “floating promotions”, the owners of which are unknown.
On Russian scale, the plant is not a large manufacturer, but by the standards of the Pskov region it is a fairly large enterprise, which costs somewhere in 7-8th place among companies in the entire region.
Why did you contact the City Duma with a request to sell part of municipal shares?
At first, it was all the same in whose ownership there were shares, the main thing was to solve production, social and personnel issues.
But today's economic situation dictates the need for the technical and technological restructuring of the enterprise. For example, the equipment of the bakery is already 56 (fifty -six!) Years. Our people retire at 55! Hoping, as before, is no longer possible for cheap energy and cheap labor. Without significant changes, the plant will go into a dead end situation.
For eleven years, we did not feel at all that we have such a large shareholder as a municipality, although by law on joint -stock companies, owners should take care of the development of the enterprise. Now, when there was a worthy investor, the city administration supported the management of the plant and agreed to sell part of the municipal package of shares.
How do you assess the course of discussion in the City Duma proposals on the sale of part of the municipal package of shares of Pskov Bakery OJSC?
I come there a second time. I am dumbfounded by the illiteracy and irresponsibility of deputies in decision -making. My deep conviction that the city has already been damaged. The second time I try to work with the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, they should come in June, and now I do not know what to say to them. The past meeting of the Duma simply struck me. There is a feeling that the deputies, only having come to the session, read the agenda and therefore ask such questions ...
The management of our enterprise has found a way to attract such a huge amount of finances for the development of production, which would allow the plant not only to much increase the competitiveness in the market of the North-West, but also to increase its share on it. The issues have been worked out with companies that will carry out reconstruction, and with the company allocating money for this (and this is not about loans, but about the funds remaining at the enterprise). We are always talking about replenishing the budget, about the development, support of enterprises, some part of the funds are allocated for these purposes ...
We offered the Duma a solution that five times increases our deductions to the city budget, but they say: “No need”! Some of the deputies suddenly became economists and began to unfoundedly discuss whether our proposal is profitable or not. And this despite statistics, despite the fact that we worked for ten years, made plans.
A misunderstanding of this situation, losing the problems facing the company, can lead to its bankruptcy. This is possible, a conscious policy - to lead the enterprise to bankruptcy and arrange a division.
To delay the solution that is advantageous to the city and the plant means either not to understand the tasks facing people who come to power, or consciously bring the enterprise to bankruptcy. And not only the enterprise, but also the economic base of the city.
But entrepreneur Anatoly Tikhanov expressed doubt about the economic validity of your proposal ...
When a person is engaged in a different type of business, he does not feel what industrial production is. If he says that he knows better profitability in industry, the question arises, is this not being done consciously in order to destroy an economically stable enterprise?
If the deputy Anatoly Tikhanov does not agree with the assessment of the value of the shares, then the law clearly prescribes that their value is determined not by the director of the enterprise, but by independent appraisers. And each shareholder has the right to verify the conclusion of a particular evaluating company, hiring its own appraiser.
Why did you decide to sell only 24% of the shares, and not the entire municipal package?
Let's start with at least five, with ten percent of the shares! In the absence of responsibility, when we see that the comrades are sitting, making decisions and do not bear any responsibility for them, I would like to suggest such a thing: make a regulation on the legal responsibility of deputies for the decisions adopted in the charter.
When people live at the expense of taxes collected from us and dictate, develop or bend this or another enterprise, it smells of corruption.
Deputies proposed to find some other way to attract investment instead of selling a share of municipal shares to the venture fund of the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development. What can it be for a method?
Over the past year, the decline in industrial production in Russia and in the Pskov region, including amounted to almost 20%. Engineering is actually worth it, mainly the raw material industries work. The growth of the internal gross product is 4% per year, for America, where it is completely different than ours, maybe a high indicator, but for Russia it is almost nothing.
Domestic companies have no own funds for development, the banking system is not ready to lend to industry. Oil magnates will not give money either, they have other worries. Only investors such as EBRR remain.
The bank expressed his readiness to invest a lot of money in the bakery. I know similar projects of the EBRD at the enterprises of Russia only with the seaport of St. Petersburg and the pulp and paper plant in Petrozavodsk. Here the investments came to Pskov. And the deputies say: “You will invite the director of the Investment Bank of the EBRD, let him report with us, at a meeting of the City Duma that he sees and plans.” This is insanity.
What do you think, who could be beneficial to bring the plant to bankruptcy? Have you received proposals for the sale of the company?
Recently, I personally have not received such proposals. There used to be such proposals, there were attempts to mass buying up shares. I went to the Duma with a proposal to attract such a large and serious investor in order to eliminate the possibility of buying up shares with third parties, to exclude the possibility of re-profiling the plant, redirecting financial flows from the city budget. Destroying the economy of the city is a conscious position. We are contesting her.
In Russia, there are many examples as you like, when the company was artificially bankrupt and after that it received new owners. After all, look, no one pays attention to many enterprises erasing a miserable existence. But as soon as someone gets to their feet, you can immediately hear: “And I?!”, “And I?!”, “And I?!”, “And I stood nearby!”.
Are the names of those people who can be related to attempts to change the owner of the Pskov Bakery OJSC?
Such a group definitely exists. Her interests, I suppose, were reflected by those four deputies. Talking about the specific surnames of applicants for property today is not serious.
But, on the other hand, even buying these 51% of the shares, it will not work out to change the owner, only through court litigation. And litigation is also the destruction of the enterprise.
Will you again make an offer to sell municipal shares to the May session of the City Duma?
Certainly. Moreover, I will ask the deputies to entrust those colleagues who disagree with our proposal to develop an alternative proposal to develop the bakery.
After the session, you mentioned that “thanks to” this decision is lost almost a billion rubles of tax revenues. This is nearly the annual budget of Pskov. Where does this figure come from?
With the advent of the investor, the capitalization of the enterprise would sharply have grown. Property tax, and from next year and value added tax will just be given such an amount. I cannot explain the opposition to this. As far as I know, alternative proposals for investment and budget filling have not been received from anyone.
I think that not only industrialists, but also the city administration will be difficult to work with such a Duma. Instead of development, move forward, she says: “Why?” If this money entered the budget, would the question arose about increasing the rent for citizens, would it be necessary to take a loan to pay wage debts?!
Talked by Konstantin Schmoraga.
In the photo: the shares of the Pskov bakery were no less attractive than its products.
From the editorial office. The Pskov province will carefully monitor the development of the situation and is ready to provide the opportunity to speak out to all interested parties.