In early January 2010, it became known that the anti-extremist warning issued to the Yakutsk Vecherniy newspaper by the Roskomnadzor Administration for the Republic of Sakha on February 11, 2009, remains in force, and has not been withdrawn by the court, as we reported earlier .
Recall that on January 30, 2009, the weekly published an interview with the Yakut poet Sofron Osipov, which contained obviously xenophobic statements. However, these statements belonged only to the poet, and the negative attitude towards them on the part of the journalist was clearly formulated.
On February 11, 2009, the editors of the weekly received an anti-extremist warning from the Roskomnadzor Administration for the Republic of Yakutia, but they did not agree with it and challenged the warning in the arbitration court.
On June 23, 2009, the Arbitration Court of the Republic of Sakha considered the claim of the founder of the Yakutsk Vecherniy newspaper LLC Vesti against the Roskomnadzor Administration for the Republic of Sakha and canceled the warning on formal grounds .
In turn, the Roskomnadzor Administration for Yakutia did not agree with the court decision and challenged it in a higher court.
On August 25, 2009, the Fourth Arbitration Court of Appeal (Chita) considered the appeal of Roskomnadzor and ruled that the first instance judgment was set aside on the grounds that the case was not subject to arbitration.
The founders of the publication did not agree with this decision, and challenged it in the Federal Arbitration Court of the East Siberian District. On December 7, 2009, this court agreed that the case was not subject to arbitration (recall that on October 6, 2009, a meeting of the Presidium of the Supreme Arbitration Court of Russia was held, the decision of which also states that challenging anti-extremist warnings, contrary to established practice, is not within the competence arbitration and henceforth must be dealt with by the courts of general jurisdiction).
Thus, the warning to the Yakutsk Vecherniy weekly, which has never been considered on the merits, remains in force. In fact, the weekly became a hostage to a situation similar to the one in which Novaya Gazeta in Petersburg found itself: the uncertainty of the legal norm (in this case, in terms of the procedure for contesting a warning) and following the established tradition of applying to arbitration in this situation, led to the fact that despite for a long time and a series of litigations, the question of the legality of the warning was never resolved.
Whether Yakutsk Vecherniy will challenge the warning in a court of general jurisdiction is unknown.
In the near future, we plan to publish court decisions in the Yakutsk Vecherny case.
Information provided by the Office of Roskomnadzor for the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia)