The regional administration is trying to participate in business on a par with local oligarchs
If you ask a person living in any other region of Russia what he knows about today's Pskov region, the Liberal Democratic Party and the alcohol industry will certainly be mentioned.
The reality, of course, is more complicated, although it is impossible to deny the significance of these two factors. Back in the Soviet Union, the region was traditionally considered economically backward, and with the beginning of the reforms of the 90s, the region entered a peak, from which it still cannot get out. Perhaps, the region's recently adopted budget for 2001 speaks most clearly of this: the share of federal assistance in total revenues exceeds seventy percent.
Political science preamble
The difficult socio-economic situation in which the region is today is not disputed by almost anyone. Such assessments are allowed not only by experts who may be suspected of bias, but also by quite official persons. The most recent example is Lyubov Sovershayeva, Deputy Plenipotentiary of the President for the North-West, who was in the region with an inspection.
A little less unanimity is usually shown when explaining the reasons for this state of affairs. However, most of our Pskov interlocutors agreed on the fault of the regional "oligarchs", who actually "privatized" the most profitable sectors of the regional economy: cargo transit, trade, alcohol production. However, it should be noted that it is precisely in these very “oligarchic” sectors that the general crisis is felt much weaker, and, say, the forest industry, which still remains “ownerless”, is not at all a model of prosperity.
In the economic life of the Pskov region, a phenomenon that is not typical for the rest of Russia has developed today. Its administrative head, Yevgeny Mikhailov, never managed to achieve the status of a regional celestial, usual for a Russian governor, on whose exclusive will the fate of one or another representative of the local business community depends. The new administration, which failed to head the regional business, essentially had no choice but to occupy the niche of one of the regional "oligarchs" and thereby receive its "legitimate" dividends from being in power.
Apparently, the main question that arises in this connection is what caused such an uncharacteristic role of the regional administration. To answer it, you need to go back to history. The current governor, Yevgeny Mikhailov, entered the regional leadership in 1996 on the shoulders of Russia's chief liberal democrat. With the slogan "To every woman a man, and to every man a bottle of vodka", a convincing victory was won. It is alleged that Moscow did not interfere with Mikhailov, thus thanking Zhirinovsky for his loyalty in the recently concluded presidential elections. With such significant support, Mikhailov could afford not to "re-recruit" the local economic elite.
Almost immediately after the fanfare died down, the newly elected governor found that control over most of the regional resources was already in someone’s hands, and there was no way to force dissent to “share”: Moscow’s support turned out to be very short-lived. Yevgeny Mikhailov himself did not possess the necessary qualities.
“The Pskov region was chronically unlucky with strategic leaders… They simply didn't exist. The process of managing the region in 1986-2000 resembles a feverish change of managers at a candle factory. The only difference is who used this factory and how,” says Lev Shlosberg, one of the leaders of the Pskov branch of Yabloko.
Engines of the economy
We must give the regional authorities their due - they found a way out fairly quickly. True, they had to go a way that was not quite usual for state authorities - to find unoccupied economic niches and transfer them under their tutelage. Almost immediately after the new head of the region took office, the state unitary enterprise "Pskov-Alco" was created, which began selling the relevant products. Administrative levers were used without any twinge of conscience to fight his competitors. So, in 1997, CJSC German, a factory for the production of low-alcohol drinks with a 100-year history, was brought into bankruptcy.
Having become the sole controller of the local production of alcohol, the administration began to carry out an equally important task: protecting the regional market from the products of someone else's production. The production and sale of alcoholic beverages were subject to sales tax incentives (0.1% instead of 5%) and property taxes (0.1% instead of 2%). A special law was also adopted, allowing subsidies for wine and vodka enterprises from the regional budget. In 1999, 10 million rubles were allocated for subsidies to the alcohol industry from the regional budget, in 2000 - 48 million, and in 2001 they are going to allocate supposedly 84 million. And this despite the fact that, for example, in 1999 the budget had a deficit of 51 %, and the entire volume of budget expenditures of the region for the current year - 2.8 billion rubles.
The last pockets of free competition disappeared from the regional alcohol market by the end of 1998: from now on, vodka and other strong drinks were produced and sold exclusively by enterprises that were part of the de facto pro-governor alcohol holding.
However, despite the obvious success of its alcoholic know-how, the Pskov administration still does not look like the main, much less the only regional "oligarch": it is believed that certain individuals can and do compete with it.
First of all, we are talking about 52-year-old Viktor Bibikov, the founder and director of the Andromeda holding and, concurrently, co-chairman of the regional Union of Commodity Producers. Andromeda includes a cable plant, an electrical equipment plant, the Priozernoe agro-fish firm (a former fishing collective farm), the best hotel in the city, Rizhskaya (received from the former head of the region, Tumanov, in exchange for refusing to run for governor), restaurant "Andromeda" and management "Remstroybyt". Mikhail Khoronen, who was elected mayor of Pskov in 2000, is believed to be a protege of Mr. Bibikov.
However, according to a number of observers, in the last couple of years, the position of the head of Andromeda in the Pskov table of ranks has somewhat weakened. A new character has come to the fore among the leaders of Pskov business - the general director of CJSC Rostek-Terminal, 43-year-old Mikhail Bryachak. His company specializes in servicing all transit cargo transportation across the region from Russia and the CIS to European countries (primarily to the Baltic countries).
In general, the transit and customs business is important for the region, which can hardly be overestimated: the region borders on Belarus, Latvia and Estonia, and this, perhaps, is the main feature of both its geographical and economic position. According to Lev Shlosberg, “for the Pskov region, the concept of a “gateway from Russia to Europe” is not just a geographical location, but a mission. A few years later, after the undoubted admission of Estonia and Latvia to the European Union, another economic reality will come close to the border of the region. But the Pskov region is completely unprepared for this meeting.”
This geopolitical advantage still needs to be able to take advantage of, and this is exactly where difficulties arise, which, however, are in many respects of a completely objective nature. Despite the fact that, ideally, it is the Pskov region that, like no other, is suitable for the role of the main link connecting the huge Russian market with the markets of its closest European neighbors, in practice, the current volume of transit traffic through its territory is significantly lower than even back in 1992. Apparently, the region still has not managed to recover from the shocks of the August crisis, when the volume of rail transport fell by half, water transport by almost five times, road transport by six, and air transport stopped altogether.
However, even in this state, the transport network of the region provides about 10% of the total cargo traffic of Russia's exports (moreover, the total share of Russia's exports through the Baltic states is approximately 17%). Moreover, these figures obviously do not take into account the volume of both "gray" and openly smuggled cargo.
There are legends about how Mr. Bryachak managed to "saddle" this gold mine in Pskov, which agree that the key episode was his acquaintance in the mid-90s with the then head of the Airborne Forces, General Podkolzin. Some time later, an ordinary car mechanic, Mr. Bryachak, became one of the official suppliers of the Airborne Forces, and his business immediately went uphill.
Next Generation
In the past few years, among the leading Pskov businessmen, new faces have appeared that do not fit into the traditional scheme for acquiring and increasing capital for the region. In addition, in addition to developing their own business, they are actively going into power, which this government frankly does not like. In response, she tries to show hitherto unprecedented rigidity.
The most interesting character from the "new" ones is Mikhail Kuznetsov, State Duma deputy from the Pskov region. Kuznetsov has been a deputy for the second term, and at the time of his first election in 1995 he was barely 27 years old. He had nothing to do with Pskov before his election, he was born in Tyumen (where, as they say, he studied in the same class as the aluminum king Oleg Deripaska). He moved to Moscow, where he worked his way up from an expert in the operations department of the Industriya-Service bank to a member of the Board of MDM Bank. For a long time after Mikhailov was elected governor, they cooperated, and the detractors of the deputy claimed that he controlled almost all the budget funds of the region. Apparently, these statements had some grounds - in Rusregionbank, with which Kuznetsov had the closest contacts, the accounts of many committees of the regional administration were accumulated. However, after shortly before the 2000 gubernatorial election, former comrades-in-arms dispersed and turned into bitter enemies, the accounts were seized. The place of the court bank was not empty for long: it was occupied by the Baltic Bank and the PSB, who came from St. Petersburg, who provided Mikhailov with serious support in the elections. However, this blow did not become fatal either for the deputy or for “his” bank: Kuznetsov announced that he would continue to fight for regional power.
The story of the struggle of the president of the NPN Production Association LLC (which includes the Plastprom plant, the Pskov Gear Plant, two large and, apparently, the best stores in Pskov) ended differently, Igor Savitsky. He was elected to the City Duma, then to the Regional Assembly. Experts confidently predicted his participation in the gubernatorial campaign, but this was opposed by the regional authorities. Checks of the tax police, the opening of a criminal case, the arrest of employees - in a word, a familiar scenario. As a result, Savitsky backed down, declared his support for Governor Mikhailov, and all problems with law enforcement agencies were resolved almost at the same moment.
In a word, the first stage of the struggle between the "old" and "new" generations of Pskov oligarchs ended with the victory of businessmen of the "traditional" type for the region.
Choice spanning four years
However, it is far from certain that their success will be final: the “new generation” of Pskov oligarchs seems more promising even in electoral terms. In the gubernatorial elections held in November 2000, Duma member Kuznetsov spoke at the level of his "senior comrades", gaining 15% of the vote against the same 15% for Bibikov and 6% for Bryachak. However, Yevgeny Mikhailov defeated them all anyway - the 28% of the votes he collected with a 54% turnout ensured that the governor retained power for the next four years.
The result of these elections may seem paradoxical. Far from being the most popular among the people, the governor confidently defeated his popular and authoritative business opponents. Although it can be said in another way: the "state" oligarch seemed to the voters nicer than his commercial opponents. However, this does not mean the end of the history of the Pskov "oligarchy". Rather, quite the contrary: nothing threatens him in the coming years, and it is Mikhailov's victory that marks this fact.
For both the current Pskov administration and large regional business are still too weak. The first is to impose its own rules of the game on the local business community and become, in fact, the only subject of economic initiative in the region. The second is to point local authorities to the only place appropriate for them as an impartial arbiter who does not interfere in a specific economic process.
In a word, the status quo has been preserved. However, the fall into the abyss cannot continue forever. Who - government or business - will be able to seize the initiative at a decisive moment and overturn the opponent, it is impossible to predict today. Although it is the answer to this question that will have a decisive influence on the fate of the region in the very near future.
Artemy SMIRNOV,
Kirill Kozhin.
Magazine "Expert North-West", No. 2 (31) dated February 5, 2001 St. Petersburg - Pskov.