In previous episodes: - A decoy and a bribe thrown out of a car - Who is the main witness for the prosecution Valitov, he is also a bribe giver, he is also a "colonel of the SVR" - What is in the wiretaps of the country's chief investigator and what does Deputy Prime Minister Sechin have to do with it enriched himself on the Yukos affair
So, what is the bottom line after reading the multi-volume case of Dmitry Dovgy and talking with people related to the war of Russian power clans?
In September 2007, the Investigative Committee under the Prosecutor's Office (SKP) was created. As a result, the Prosecutor General's Office was deprived of the function of the investigation, which was the reason for the aggravation of the war of the security forces for shadow financial flows, for political influence and the levers of economic redistribution, which are in the hands of those who can both imprison and ruin, and not notice the corpus delicti. Dmitry Dovgy, who had worked for many years under the head of the Investigative Committee Alexander Bastrykin, but had no experience in practical investigative work, was appointed head of the Main Investigation Department (GSU), becoming the only, but key, personnel creature of Bastrykin in the formation of the staff of the new department.
By the end of 2007, relations between the Prosecutor General's Office and the Investigative Committee had escalated to the limit. Resonant criminal cases were used to clarify the relationship. Prosecutors have begun an all-Russian check of their former colleagues for corruption. And in early 2008, there were persistent rumors about the imminent resignation of Bastrykin.
In March 2008, Investigative Committee investigators Zygmund Logis and Sergei Chernyshov wrote reports to the presidential administration on Bastrykin's right hand, Dmitry Dovgy, in which they accused their boss of two episodes of bribery. Dovgy was suspended for the duration of the inspection. And although none of the denunciations was confirmed, at the end of April the head of the GSU was fired, and in August a criminal case was opened for the third bribe. Dovgiy was accused of receiving 750,000 euros from businessman Ruslan Valitov through the mediation of the former investigator of the Main Military Prosecutor’s Office Andrei Sagura, who allegedly paid to avoid criminal liability in the case of stealing money from a subsidiary of the bankrupt Yukos.
But Valitov, before the creation of the UPC, for some reason, was already involved in the case of embezzlement in Tomskneft as a witness, although all his accomplices (Sergei Shimkevich, Oleg Kolyada, Oleg Klyucherev) were arrested back in 2006 - early 2007, before the formation UPC. Everyone was arrested, except for Valitov, who bought Investsotsbank with allegedly stolen money from Tomskneft and, according to the operational information attached to the case, could be the main developer of the entire embezzlement scheme.
There can be several explanations for this discrepancy. Firstly, there were persistent rumors in the Prosecutor General’s Office, and then in the UPC: Investsotsbank could be used for financial operations of the Foreign Intelligence Service, and Valitov was called almost the head of the department of this service, so it’s better not to touch all this. Secondly, in the wiretaps of Dovgiy, Sagura's intermediary and Valitov's briber, the latter casually mentions that a long time ago, perhaps even before the appearance of the UPC, he handed over a bribe to someone upstairs. And, by the way, he hints to Dovgy that he would like to return this money if the head of the GSU is reinstated with his help. The prosecution subsequently interpreted these money transfers as a direct demand from Valitov to return the bribe that Dovgy allegedly received from him. Dovgy's silence was taken as his consent.
But Valitov was still arrested. They kept him in a pre-trial detention center for several days, where he “confessed” to giving a bribe to Dovgy, was released, went with recording equipment to a meeting with the ex-head of the Main Investigative Directorate and, as a result, was generally released from any responsibility for anything.
There is little evidence of guilt presented by the investigation in the Dovhyi case, to put it mildly. First, the head of the UPC paid close attention to a number of criminal cases, including the Valitov-Tomskneft case (which is part of his duties). Secondly, the “intermediary” Sagura and the “bribe taker” Dovgy were at the same time in the same place, where, according to the investigation, the transfer of money took place. (True, the place is Technicalny Lane, where the UPC is located, and Sagura's phone billings show that he drove by in a car - that is, the only way to transfer a bribe is to throw money on the street in a wine box under the office window.) By the way, the investigators did not even bother to check whether the fingerprints of Dovgy and Sagura were on the money, and most importantly, whether they were placed in that box at all.
And third. Actually, the wiretapping of the negotiations of Dovgy, Sagura and Valitov, who miraculously escaped criminal prosecution, promised to arrange an audience with the director of the FSB for the dismissed and dreaming of being reinstated as the country's chief investigator.
There is only one episode in the wiretaps that compromises Dovgy, which, perhaps, had the greatest influence on the jury in reaching the verdict. But Dovgy himself did not participate in this conversation: this is a dialogue between the mediator Andrey Sagura and decoy Ruslan Valitov. The mediator convinces the bribe giver not to talk about money in front of Dovgy.
Sagura: “Well, for example, one interesting question. He ( Dovgy . - R.A. ) says: “Well, as for what is left with me ... let's return to this issue. And how will I approach this now, I will say: “Give it back”? He did what you asked, what I agreed with him.
Valitov: “That is, he still believes that Verkholaz ( this is how the head of the Investigative Committee Alexander Bastrykin is called behind his back. - R.A. ) took the money and took it there? I asked him: “But Alexander Ivanovich seems to be out of touch?”
Sagura: "He is in the subject both morally and financially."
However, in the same wiretap: “Dima didn’t receive anything from you. He sits too, pouted, says: “I didn’t understand something ... I didn’t understand.”
Sagura at the trial explained his words by the fact that he was specially playing along with Valitov: he understood that he was recording the conversation, that he needed to report to the “seniors” for the money that he transferred to someone even before the formation of the UPC. In this regard, questions arise. How would this "play along" work if Bastrykin began to defend his squire Dovgy? And wasn't this whole conversation pre-rehearsed to record? If not, then why were only Saguru and Dovgia tried?
But, on the other hand, some of our sources in the UPC believe that there really was a bribe, but only at the time it did not reach the addressee and settled in the pockets of intermediaries. For example, the same Sagura or the investigators ... The one who needed it knew about it and “remembered” it at the right moment: when Dovgy was removed and an investigation was carried out according to the reports of the investigators Logis and Chernyshov.
It is likely that Dmitry Dovgy deserved criminal prosecution - it is known that angels are not kept in such positions, and that the number of "politically and economically motivated" criminal cases investigated under the supervision of the head of the Main Investigative Directorate is considerable - so, to be honest , then the corpus delicti could be found, but only in the fact for which he was convicted? Or, to be honest, then it would not have cost one accomplice?
About naive courtiers, or the collapse of the tandem
Not Newton's binomial: the defining quality that the chief investigator of the country should possess is loyalty and readiness to skillfully stage criminal cases that are beneficial to the authorities, and, on the contrary, turn a blind eye to unprofitable ones. Dovgy accepted these rules of the game, but got confused about which branch of power, which tower should be chosen. He was not a member of any of the warring power clans and mistakenly believed that Bastrykin alone would be enough for him. Only at these imperious heights, where Dovgy ascended not by professional merit, but by coincidence, can any insurance fail and any cliff turn out to be unreliable if the benefit lies elsewhere. Although I might think...
(From the wiretaps of Dovgy, Sagura and Valitov)
Dovgy: “My old friend, a police colonel ... they started with him ( Bastrykin. - R.A. ) in the criminal investigation department in 1975. That is, he was already a senior opera, and Bastrykin was sent to him as a young oper. And he learned from him. Slava has known him since Bastrykin organized the Civil Service Academy in St. Petersburg. Slava helped him a lot. Including ... they have a very nice mansion on Vasilevsky Island, two-story, chic ... Slava helped him, and he ( Bastrykin. - R.A. ) took him to himself, well, in terms of the economic part, as a vice-rector. When he did everything for him, he ( Bastrykin . - R. A. ) later also said to him: “Come on, fuck ... quit, that’s all.” <…>
Dovgy: “Then, when we worked in the police, he also accused a man, our mutual friend, of going to banks. For some reason this is a painful topic for him. Allegedly, this one went to banks and asked for an interest-free loan for housing, and in return he promised to resolve any issues with everyone through Bastrykin. Well, this is nonsense ... Can a normal person believe this? And he believed. And after that, he was also kicked out of there. Moreover, he gave the command to Aulov ( the head of the operational-investigative department of the Federal Drug Control Service. - R.A. ), his friend, so that he was caught on drugs and locked up there ... "
So when and, most importantly, why did Dovgy himself become unnecessary and dangerous? There is one subtle but very important detail in the materials of the criminal case. In the structure of the GSU there are two departments for the investigation of particularly important cases. Since the formation of the UPC, these departments have had no leaders. And in March 2008, a week before the removal of Dovgy, Sergey Markelov was appointed to the post of head of the first department, who would later take the place of the head of the GSU. Most likely, even then, even before the start of checking the denunciations of investigators Chernyshov and Logis, they decided to remove Dovgy.
Bastrykin stated at the trial that he had almost no disagreements with his former subordinate. With the exception of the Storchak case (Dovgy believed that in the episode with the Kuwaiti debt there were no grounds for initiating a criminal case) and Dovgy's attempt to change the measure of restraint to a written undertaking not to leave the terminally ill Yukos manager Vasily Aleksanyan. Well, when the reports of Chernyshov and Logis lay on Bastrykin's desk, the patience of the director of the UPC allegedly ran out of patience, and he suggested that his subordinate quietly quit. There were also verbal denunciations on a “sick” topic: allegedly Dovgy again goes to some banks, and it seems that these visits were even recorded by security cameras.
God is with them, with banks, who among the top officials does not go there ... But the fact that Dovgy, inexperienced in investigative and court affairs, climbed (and no matter with what intentions) into the most painful criminal cases for the "power tower": Storchak, Aleksanyan and Yukos, Bulbov and Tomskneft, and, according to some reports, the case of the St. Petersburg authoritative businessman Kumarin-Barsukov, could not be liked.
There were denunciations, Dovgy was fired. And if he quietly left for a teaching job, they would most likely forget about him and there would be no story with a bribe from Valitov. But the former head of the GSU behaved "unsystematically."
First, he decided through the court to recognize his dismissal as illegal. Secondly, he began to distribute frank interviews in which he told how Bastrykin allegedly forced him to illegally initiate cases against Bulbov and Storchak, how only FSB operational information becomes the basis for criminal prosecution, and in general, how the entire investigative system of Russia is rotten.
But at the same time, he does not lose hope of remaining in the system, and in one of the clumsy interviews he again tries to prove himself a subtle courtier: he declares that the person who ordered the murder of Anna Politkovskaya, “according to their firm conviction,” is Boris Berezovsky. But this signal: they say, look what they have all come to, but I am at the same time with you, I understand everything and unconditionally agree with your every word, was sent into the void. And a day later, Dovgy writes a letter to Vladimir Putin, in which he succinctly, but more textured, repeats everything: about FSB information, and about fake criminal cases ... Otherwise, the addressee is not in the know.
And what is the reaction?
In the wiretaps, Dovgy recalls with resentment how, at some party, even before the initiation of a criminal case against him, he accidentally crossed paths with the addressee. He pretended not to notice him and turned away without shaking his hand.
Who ordered?
The first version is "vindictive". After the dismissal of Dovgy, the media named Prosecutor General Yuri Chaika as the person most interested in this scandal. Like, the Prosecutor General's Office decided in this way to discredit the head of the Investigative Committee, or even achieve his dismissal, if Bastrykin stood up for his subordinate. Dmitry Dovgy was more specific in the wiretaps: he suggested that Sergei Ivanov, who previously headed the 18th Directorate for Investigating Particularly Important Cases in the Prosecutor General's Office, could have initiated the scandal, and said that Ivanov, who did not get into the staff of the Investigative Committee, almost left Dovgia in the face the keys to the office.
The second version is Yukosov's. Our sources in law enforcement agencies do not really believe in the version of revenge - the prosecutors could have had a motive, but they did not have the main thing - the means to implement it. In their opinion, it was his promiscuity that played a key role in the scandal with Dovgiy: it was impossible to get into cases “motivated” at the very top and given to the UPC not for investigation, but for execution. Including cases of embezzlement from the "daughters" of Yukos.
Since 2003, there has been no tastier piece for investigators than the Yukos case. Unsold oil, assets and outstanding promissory notes worth billions of rubles. And Yukos investigators were de facto subordinate not to Bastrykin or Chaika, but to the one who gave the command "face" and who was interested in discovering the money of "enemies of sovereign democracy" and finding the "correct use" for them. These people were not interested in the small crumbs that fell into the pockets of the performers.
And Dmitry Dovgy decided to check the activities of investigators Khatypov and Nikolaev, who were involved in Tomskneft. He instructed the important Sharan Elsultanov to clarify the fate of the remaining bills of the Trust Bank, bought with the stolen money of Tomskneft. Dovgy wanted to clarify in whose interests Khatypov and Nikolaev acted, in whose presence the banker Kolyada issued a power of attorney to his wife for the remaining shares of Trust, which were subsequently sold to his companion Yurov 2.5 times cheaper than the market value. And there were enough such cases related to the property of Yukos ...
Yes, according to the results of the check, Elsultanov refused to initiate a criminal case. But we do not know the details, which, perhaps, were not reflected in his decision. And we don’t know why Elsultanov, the best investigator of 2008, after the story with Dovgiy, did not receive a single criminal case, all the time working only in investigative groups?
It seems that Dovgy realized what he had gotten himself into much later. When Valitov became very interested at the meetings, did Dovgy have some compromising evidence on Deputy Prime Minister Sechin? But at the moment when Dovgy, perhaps, realized this, it was already too late. The verdict was signed. And the one who did not extend his hand to him, most likely, knew about it well even before the initiation of the criminal case.
Which of these versions is closer to the truth - in the near future we will not know. It may also turn out that in the story of the condemnation of the country's chief investigator, not two, but many more components were intertwined - well, the stars lay down like that. But in any case, it seems that Dmitry Dovgy has become a common bargaining chip in the shadowy and brutal war of power clans. And this war has not ended ... Therefore, the surname Dovgy will soon be used as a common noun.
(Ending. Beginning at No. 3, 5, 7)