Rural teachers met a new heating season without compensation assigned to the purchase and delivery of solid fuel
In the Pskov region, the heating season 2008-2009 began! Not today, of course, and not even yesterday, but two months ago. The heating season in our Palestines begins in October and ends in April. Why is this priceless information? To remind: “Until recently, partial monetary compensation for the acquisition and delivery of solid fuel: firewood or coal was supposed to certain categories of citizens working and living in rural areas in the territory of the Pskov region”.

True, the monthly compensation provided for by the Law of the Pskov Region dated April 5, 2005 No. 427-OZ “On measures of social support for certain categories of citizens working and living in rural areas in the Pskov region” was very partial. And she did not compensate to rural specialists the acquisition and delivery of solid fuel: for 230-260 rubles per month, prescribed in the law, for the entire heating season you can not buy firewood [ 1 ].
And this has already contradicted federal law. P. 5 of Art. 55 of the Law of the Russian Federation of July 10, 1992 “On Education” suggests that teachers of educational institutions in the manner prescribed by the legislation of the Russian Federation enjoy the right to free residential area with heating and lighting in rural areas. The amount and procedure for reimbursement of expenses related to the provision of these social support measures are established by legislative acts of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.
Moreover, in accordance with Art. 153 of Federal Law No. 122-ФЗ is not allowed to reduce the total amount of financing of benefits and payments, as well as a deterioration in the conditions for the provision of benefits for categories of persons who used the benefit in kind.
That is, no matter what capabilities of its budget proceeds the subject of the federation, but compensation to rural specialists - “take it out in full” if they decide not to provide the benefit in kind (immediately with firewood, not money).
The regional executive, and from its submission and legislative power, did not see this contradiction point blank. And then the citizens corrected them - in court.
On April 28, 2008, the Pskov Regional Court examined the application of the teacher from the Ostrovsky district Lydia Romanova on recognition by contradictory federal law and the invalid (in part) of the Law of the Pskov Region dated April 5, 2005 No. 427-OZ “On measures of social support of certain categories of citizens working and residents living in the territory of the Pskov region”.
The court recognized as contradicting federal legislation to paragraphs 4 of paragraph 1 of Article 4 of this Law (the same paragraph on 230-260 rubles) from the moment the court decision comes into force.
The Pskov Regional Assembly of Deputies and the administration of the Pskov region filed cassation complaints to the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation. But on July 23, 2008, the Judicial Collegium for Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation left the decision of the Pskov Regional Court, and cassation complaints disbursed.
And thus rural specialists in the Pskov region ... were left without compensation. Recall that it was the prospect of such a dangerous development of the legislative framework in our region for a long time that Lidia Vasilievna Romanov for a long time from challenging this “cheap” paragraph of the regional law in the regional court. She, or rather - her representatives “beat off” the compensation, laid to her as a rural teacher in full, in the Ostrovsky City Court for several heating seasons. We can say, by private order: Lidia Vasilievna filed an application with the Ostrovsky city court, it was considered and the requirements satisfied it. Her personal requirements.
Then the Ostrovsky city court was tired. And he clearly made it clear to Lidia Vasilievna and her representatives that we must go to the regional court and challenge the regional law. Which was done - with all the leaked consequences.
Thus, after the abolition of the law, both colleagues Lidia Vasilievna and Lidia Vasilievna herself were left without compensation.
I had to use the old scheme: on the eve of the heating season, go to the Ostrovsky City Court of the Pskov region. During the trial, the representative of the territorial administration of the Ostrovsky district of the Main State Administration of Social Development of the Pskov Region explained that since the Pskov Region Law on partial compensation for free heating at the time of consideration was declared invalid, and the new version of this clause has not yet been adopted, Lidia Vasilievna should be refused.
The Ostrovsky City Court habitually indicated that the right of teachers to a living area with heating and lighting in rural areas is a federal measure of social support and this support measure should be provided in the manner prescribed by federal legislation, and in the transition from the provision of natural benefits to the provision of monetary compensation, the level of social protection of this category of persons should not be reduced.
Thus, on October 8, 2008, the next statement by Lidia Vasilievna Romanova was once again satisfied, the district department of social development compensation for the acquisition of solid fuel will be paid in full (about 3 thousand rubles a month).
And no amendments to the regional law regarding compensation to rural specialists for the acquisition of solid fuel have been made. In April, the paragraphs contrary to federal legislation were canceled, in July a complete and unconditional confirmation of the validity of this cancellation was obtained. And all! There is no paragraph - there is no problem. That is, there is no compensation to all those who do not guess or do not dare to go to court.
We contacted the chairman of the Pskov Regional Assembly of Deputies Boris Polozov, who immediately understood what question was. And he explained that now "the new social code of the Pskov region is born in the bowels of the regional department of social development." There, in this code, almost all measures to social protection of the population should be reflected. In addition, in all likelihood, those "shortcomings that we, unfortunately, allow ourselves will be corrected." Boris Gennadievich did not have any more accurate information on the move. I only noticed that the Social Code can be submitted to the deputies of the regional assembly in December. And on the issue of canceling compensation to him personally, citizens did not turn to the reception.
The chairman of the Committee on Social Policy of the Regional Parliament, Alexander Khristoforov, also said that it is necessary to ask with the regional executive branch - the refinement of the law depends on them. Alexander Nikolaevich himself does not plan to show legislative initiative here and he also does not know anything about such plans of 43 colleagues.
Armen Mnatsakanyan, the head of the Main State Administration of Social Development of the Pskov Region, had more accurate information on this issue. Armen Liparitovich was somewhat corrected by Boris Gennadievich: amendments to the law will be made to the Pskov Regional Assembly of Deputies completely separately, not within the framework of the Social Code. But for sure - to the December session of this year. It is difficult to say something about the amount of compensation: the draft amendments to the law is now undergoing a procedure for approval in almost all administrations and committees of the administration of the Pskov region. And what will be the “agreed” decision on changes is still unclear. It remains only to believe that both the developers of the amendments and those who have to approve them remember the inadmissibility of violation of federal legislation: compensation should really compensate to rural specialists the cost of acquiring and delivering solid fuel in full.
And the fact that the heating season is already two months old - what can you do. Our people are amazing. Amazingly patient.
Elena Shiryaeva
1 See: E. Shiryaeva. Give and not sin // "PG", No. 33 (402) dated August 20-26, 2008