
I suspect that the epic reviews dedicated to the biennale have become rather boring to the reader; however, the phantom pain continues. Despite the fact that two reviews have already been devoted to the festival of arts, the third will have to start from the same place. Everything that can be said positive about the international forum was summarized by Irina Kulik in the judicious magazine "Kommersant-Vlast" (dated 03/07, " On toilets and exhibition halls "). Four achievements as presented by Kulik:
" 1. The Biennale has improved Russia's international image at a time when the world community is concerned that it has turned away from the path of democracy.
2. Contemporary art in Russia is increasingly associated not with the underground and dissidence, but with respectability and big money.
3. It is contemporary art that is successfully integrated into the international context, and not, say, Messrs. Shilov, Glazunov, Andriyaka and Zurab Tsereteli, favored by the Moscow authorities. Recognizing it is much more profitable than ignoring it.
4. The Moscow Biennale broke the barrier that existed between contemporary art and the general public."
There is nothing to add on the first point. Everyone liked it, even the visiting founding father of world conceptualism Joseph Kosuth, who diplomatically stated in an interview with Sergei Khachaturov and Fyodor Romer: “Holding the Biennale is an unprecedented step, including Russia in the international art discourse. Today we can definitely say: Russia is a full-fledged player in the international field" ("Vremya Novostey" dated 05.03.). This is a good thing, but there is no certainty that anyone is interested in the image and international discourse. Let's take into account: you have to pay for everything. “We are falling into the bad infinity of catching up development. Only now we are not catching up with the leader, but are trying to take our rightful modest place among developing countries” (Marina Koldobskaya, “ From the center to the edge and vice versa ,” “New Time” from 13.02.). Yaroslava Bubnova is incredibly frank: “Istanbul was the optimal model that could be adapted to Moscow” (“ The Biennale in Moscow will certainly be repeated ,” the conversation was led by Elena Titarenko, “Culture” from 17.02.). However, there is nothing surprising in the new geopolitics: “The current sluggish and timid Russian government is very afraid to take risks. But it is ready to pay dearly for “to be like people” (Marina Koldobskaya).
On the other hand, in the current situation it is very important that conservative minister Alexander Sokolov , who prefers to speak before Orthodox entrepreneurs , has a serious counterbalance: “Mikhail Shvydkoy, long known as a liberal, has recently acquired a reputation as a champion of the most progressive ideas . To a large extent, thanks to the biennale, whose organizing committee he headed" (Irina Kulik). Nobles lick - after all, the federal agent openly admits: “I don’t like this art. I’m generally conservative in my tastes” (“ Sermon of a hooligan ,” talked to Lyudmila Milevskaya, “MK-Sunday” dated 06.03.).
State control over contemporary art does not frighten me at all; Moreover, I completely share the point of view of the young Ural artist Vladimir Seleznev, who says: “He who pays calls the tune. I don’t know, maybe political strategists advised Putin to take the experience of the USA, where during the time of pop art artists of this trend were funded by the state and even the CIA" (" Artists, like the public, need to be educated ", "Expert-Ural" dated 28.02.). That is, for the final flowering of the arts, all we have to do is persuade the FSB. And everything will be fine.
On the second point, everything also looks life-affirming; the money disputes are especially encouraging. It’s not even a matter of the personal taste of some critics, who believe that for the same money everything could have been done boldly and richly (see Olga Kabanova, “ The watch has been handed over ,” Vedomosti, 02.03.). The most serious and thorough critics turn out to be precisely those who are supposed to do so according to the state - the artistic director of the State Center for Contemporary Art Leonid Bazhanov and the editor-in-chief of the "Art Journal" Viktor Misiano.
The story is like this. First, Misiano and Joseph Backstein freed Bazhanov from worries about the Russian pavilion in Venice. Then Backstein scandalously kicked Misiano out of the curatorial team. Now Misiano has appeared on the information field with an important statement: “In fact, the “official” biennale “ate” the budget of 2004 and 2005 - it is unlikely that the state will give even a penny more for contemporary art in the near future. However, according to the estimates of those who are more involved in contemporary art or less understands, all the exhibitions shown in Moscow are unlikely to have achieved that much (Tatyana Kravchenko, “ Million in the dacha outhouse ”, “Political Journal” from 28.02.). I understand. However, I am amused that our paladin of world standards now insists: “If you need to show world art in our context, then you cannot choose the works that were on “Dialectic of Hope.” In Madrid, Hanover, Paris - ok. But not with us" (Zhanna Vasilyeva, " First Pancake ", "Results" from 28.02.).
Further - even more correct: “For the first time, the state and big money came to the territory of big art. And all the mistakes of our young reformers of the 90s were immediately repeated. First of all, Western-centrism, and in grotesque forms. This is some kind of infantile provincial fascination with Western stars.” . I can assume that it was precisely this new fundamentalism of Misiano that led to the fact that he was ousted from the curatorial team - poor Backstein with his stupid letters in the authorities, it seems, was simply set up. But in the main I agree with my colleague Misiano: I would like more responsibility from the curators, as well as all sorts of intellectual fun - “conferences, debates, seminars that usually accompany large projects.” Plus good labels and other cute little things.
As for big money, as a vulgar Marxist, the new situation touches me to the extreme. Sovrisk becomes a real thing, where everything is grown-up. Like Hollywood productions, the quality of the exhibition is estimated in millions of dollars. The “Blue Noses”, who became famous for the “Video on the Knee” project, having returned to their cool places, explain to a local correspondent: “It is impossible to imagine the media projects of the “Blue Noses” in Novosibirsk, since they are high-cost and require serious technical equipment” (Irina Ulyanina, “ Moscow Biennale” showed " Blue Noses ", Titoff.ru, 11.02.). 01.03.) And, as an honest businessman, he indulges in unbridled auto-PR: “The fact is that the films I create are unusual in form and content, they are difficult to perceive and are designed for a viewer who has a certain aesthetic experience.” “The works of necrorealists are designed for a prepared audience of subtle connoisseurs of postmodernism, cinephiles, connoisseurs of trash movies, Murnau, Cocteau & Buñuel... If the sunset is captured, then it is as if in the last seconds before the Apocalypse. The audience gets bogged down in a lifeless, completely infernal environment, in which everything and everyone decays and dies in a decadently beautiful way" (“ ARTICULATION # 34 with Dmitry Barabanov ,” Artinfo.ru).
What about “Blue Noses” and necrorealists - the infection penetrates into the patented temples of the High. And a completely positive critic, without any embarrassment, reports about the exhibition of Chagall himself : “ The exhibition cost about one and a half million dollars (in addition to the state, money was invested by Vneshtorgbank, British American Tobacco Russia, several foundations and galleries)” (Sergei Khachaturov, “ Stepping in Step” ! ", "News Time" from 28.02.).
Money is money, and I, together with Faina Balakhovskaya, rejoice that “after the biennale that shook art Moscow, contemporary art has returned to its low-budget place. No matter how much we were scared that the center of creative life would move to the Russian capital and not every citizen would withstand this, the world will once again did not turn over" (" Quarterly Report ", "Vremya Novostey" dated 02.03.). But, most importantly, the biennale showed that contemporary art now has its own audience. Thoughtful Fighter Pupkin demands that something like “Tate Modern” be organized at the Lenin Museum, “because nowhere since visiting Tate Modern have I been so flattered! Extravaganza, baby!” (" Tate" on the road ", Kak dated 23.02.) If such brave fighters begin to be flattened and sausaged, victory will be ours, our cause is just. We can retire.