
So , there are two news. One is bad, the other is even better. The Coordination Council for Russian Culture met at a party at the Academy of Public Administration under the President of the Russian Federation. At it, of course, “More than fifty envoys-deputies from all over the country, together with officials of the Ministry of Culture, decided how to protect the Fatherland and its culture.” And Minister Sokolov announced the sad news: “If previously 3.4 billion rubles were supposed to be allocated from the federal budget for cultural needs in 2005, now this amount has been reduced to 1.2 billion. The remaining “cultural” funds will have to be obtained locally” ( Mikhail Malykhin. “ All power to the council ,” Novye Izvestia, March 15).
The conclusion, as always, is simple - there will be nothing to eat, fellow tribesmen. What should I do? Do you want to eat? The enemies of true culture were pointed out by a direct and purely concrete man, Andrei Konchalovsky - this is the Market, the Urinal and the Pickled Shark. As a result , “Marketing has become the main driving force in the development of civilization, because the strength of marketing is that the quality of a product is less important than the quality of its advertising - after all, the result measured by the profit received is important. It is difficult not to draw very sad conclusions regarding the prospects for the development of Western civilization” (Andrey Konchalovsky, “ Victory of the market over art ”, “Rossiyskaya Gazeta” dated 9.03.). If they are eliminated, then complete dissolution in heaven will begin. Another important person, vice-president of the Academy of Russian Art Evgeny Zevin, explains in the official “Russian News” dated April 15 what exactly we will eat.
“Some elements of the state order are already appearing today,” concludes Evgeny Zevin. “For example, on one of the capital’s roads I recently saw a large poster with the image of Joseph Kobzon, which lists his merits. Why is this not a portrait of a leader in labor? Portraits of Vladimir Putin are carried at demonstrations, slogans professionally executed by artists. What is this if not visual propaganda?” And he immediately remembers with kind words the true adherents of culture: “For example, for a long time I did not understand why avant-garde artists were persecuted so much.” But then one day I got into a conversation with a former high-ranking KGB officer who oversaw the fine arts. To my perplexed remark, he responded as follows : “You don’t understand, we discussed this issue very carefully and found that underground painting has a strong influence on rocking society.”
Great words. The market and freethinking undermine social order. For this reason, I officially declare that I am immediately moving into the camp of market economists, monetarists and globalists. Although, of course, the matter is not as simple as it seems at first glance. Even inveterate nonconformists, who feel quite confident in the big market, are against market globalism and the globalist market; they sadly repeat that for an artist , “The talent of a businessman is more important, because a successful search for a sponsor in itself already guarantees success. Then everything works along the chain . The one who invested the money will try to justify it by hook or by crook. He will squeeze out everything possible. Thus, it turns out that success is predetermined from the very beginning” (Erik Bulatov, “ Russian art resists globalization ,” Russian Journal).
But life still goes on, no matter what. People who do not hesitate to run after sponsors continue to quietly do their high-profile deeds. For this they need to erect monuments, busts and memorial plaques. If anyone hasn’t guessed yet, then we will talk about Olga Lvovna Sviblova and the next photo month. Despite the long-standing and complicated relationship between me as a critic and Olya - a functionary and curator - I sincerely love her. For only she can say this: “When I make a festival, I exhibit only what I myself want to understand better and more. My only motivation is to give myself a buzz. I feed myself, I go crazy. I think: “Are these really my walls? " " What I do, I do out of love ", conversation between Anton Gorlenko and Olga Sviblova, "Afisha").
And in general, I express my warm agreement with the fact that “The Festival “Fashion and Style in Photography” is a holiday and a cure for spring depression” (Olga Kabanova, “ Glamour, kitsch, sur ”, “Vedomosti” from 15.03.).
True, the same Kabanova diplomatically notes , “So far, the Fashion and Style in Photography festival has not shown anything new or even, dare I say, interesting. And how good that is! , they hit the eyes so powerfully with the images of great photographers that I wanted to close my eyes” (Olga Kabanova, “ Kings of the Black and White Kingdom ,” Vedomosti, 18.03.).
But there are also much more rigoristic critics, they unload the truth - “Against the background of the general boom, as often happens, the criterion of quality is lost. In this sense, the next festival resembles a city dump or a run-down communal apartment, where rickety stools coexist with an antique buffet, and in the tattered room behind the plywood door grandma’s silver is stored. Despite the abundance of projects, “Fashion and Style” brings to our table the same artists who are also constant participants in Moscow photography festivals” (Anna Lindberg, “ Chaos of Fashion and Style ” , "Morning.Ru" from 16.03.).
Regarding the fact that the annual photography holidays began to somehow slip , only the lazy did not trample. But the whole problem is that MDF is a budgetary municipal enterprise, a very small amount is allocated for the entire holiday, Sviblova has to look for everything else from third-party sources. And there are only two of them: Western funds and transnational corporations. Of course, every time Sviblova heroically tries to bring all these rather randomly arising sentences into at least some kind of unity. We can say that she became a hostage to such a situation, and therefore it is somehow indecent to demand more from Sviblova.
For example, the hit exhibition of calendars from the Pirelli tire company, which are revered by truck drivers, was extremely appropriate in the New Manege. Next to the “Simulacra” brought from France itself, the colorful Sisi-Masisi looked very sublime. I personally found this juxtaposition strong and fresh. I’m ready to admit that this is how natural gender and age changes began for me; Olga Sviblova, alas, cannot share the modest joys of these processes.
(There are, of course, much more radical feminist approaches to the problem: “I just want to say: Russian men, go see how you can subtly appreciate female flesh!” Marina Ovsova exclaims in Moskovsky Komsomolets dated March 16).
But even not so outspoken feminists still agree that among fashionable Parisians, all sorts of simulacra cause a very flaccid erection. Which is in stark contrast to the delightful beauties for whom calendars are not written. Although, of course, there are exceptions, such as the great photographer Sarah Moon, a former model who has joined our camp of discourse chewers. Now she says : “I now look at my work with Pirelli as a mistake of youth” (Izvestia, March 16). Today, Sarah Moon, Sviblova’s favorite and therefore all photo-loving Muscovites, is busy with very important issues: “I wanted to tell a story about the liberation of women. But while working, I got a taste for it, and the struggle for freedom took on threatening proportions. And from the story of a feminist it turned into a protest against despotism, terrorism. This is my form of protest."
Renegade Exalted Sarah Moon was everyone's favorite. Especially to Yulia Loginova (" The Taming of Bluebeard ", "Moskovsky Komsomolets" from 17.03), to whom the artist said "I hate and disgust any form of authoritarianism and abuse of power." Even Sergei Safonov (“ Everything worked for us yesterday! ”, “Newspaper” dated March 16), a strict adherent of quiet but true art, even found a couple of kind words for Sarah Moon.
Nevertheless, at the festival of photography, as usual, real glamor masters set the tone, which gave Sergei Solovyov ( Antique Hollywood , New Izvestia, March 15) a reason to come to mind-blowing conclusions: “From the example of Russian and Western masters of glamor, it becomes clear that lies and fraud - this is the very style (or what is now fashionable to call “stylishness”).” I personally continue to insist, like an old man, that no one will give us deliverance other than Glamor. This is what I was convinced of when I looked at Erwin Olaf’s project at the Museum of Modern Art.
The guy is very glossy, only in the outside world gloss has reached the point of complete delight and is occupying areas previously inherent in contemporary art. Such cheerful glamorous old ladies do not evoke any sympathetic emotion, only delight and respect. Therefore, I agree with Sergei Khachaturov, who summarized in Vremya Novostei on March 15: “The ugly turns out to be a donor of the beautiful, one of the conditions for its existence.” These conclusions came to Khachaturov’s colleague in connection with the exhibition “Scandalous Peter by Joel Witkin, who within the walls of the MDF does not look so scandalous. Few corpses, cripples, transsexuals, a lot of pseudo-baroque heaps - and an indispensable, almost manic passion for details. It’s easy to imagine a person , sitting for months on a bed in some closed health facility and cherishing in his brain the smallest shades of the phantasmagoria he composed" (Velimir Moist. " Faces and Eggs ." "Gazeta.Ru from 17.03.) Our valiant art critics immediately began to remember all the freaks. and deviants of the history of art, which the maestro himself regarded with some doubt, as he said to the enlightened Sergei Khachaturov (“ Compassionate and Stylish ,” “Vremya Novostey” dated March 15): “Ugly and ugly are not an end in themselves for me. I combine beautiful and terrible objects and create my own performance, theater. I try to create a world as perfect, beautiful and deep as possible. Comparing my art to a cabinet of curiosities, to a museum of freaks is ridiculous.”
Oddly enough, the massive emergence of classical allusions in relation to Witkin is based on a simple desire to somehow protect a dear person, for: “Unlike most modern people who believe that it is appropriate to look away from death, pain or ugliness, Witkin, on the contrary , is looking for images for all these things, crowded out of culture not so much out of tact, but out of cowardice and the desire to avoid discomfort" (Irina Kulik, " Master of the Kunstkamera ", "Kommersant" dated 18.03.).
Nevertheless, the interviewers are diligently interested in how some workers react to such humanism, to which the artist responds in surprise: “Only once in Los Angeles, a radical Baptist decided to organize a picketing of my exhibition. But when the picketing participants looked at the works, they saw that these were complex things and multifaceted, were imbued with and abandoned their intentions." (Joel-Peter Witkin - Natalya Volodina, Izvestia, 17.03.). It’s not surprising, times have come to us such that the sensible Anton Gorlenko (“ Guard! ”, “Afisha” dated March 17) even picked up an article for such atrocities: “According to any Criminal Code, he is not only a sadist. He is a recidivist deconstructionist. A postmodernist. Everything They’ll get involved in the case without any problems. Moreover, all he wants is to get to his own trial.”
Our situation with this is simple - for postmodernism you are immediately dragged to jail. State prosecutor Kira Gudim at the trial in the case of the exhibition "Caution, Religion!" so she said , “The contextual nature of contemporary art required that the organizers of the exhibition take into account the traditions that have developed in Russia, an attitude towards the social role of art, as we all know, “a poet in Russia is more than a poet.” The verdict is scheduled for March 28, so the next Artificial Life will have to deal with what the verdict will mean for us all. Not only postmodernists and deconstructionists.