About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Newsletter
About RIMA
For researchers
Collection
Kronika Project
About us
Collection
For researchers
Subscribe
Our Telegram
Date
02/24/2011
Author
Boris Kagarlitsky
Source
Russkii Zhurnal
Preserved copy
Internet Archive
Translated material

Late at 150


From the editorial office . According to the International Federation for Human Rights, 640 people were killed during mass unrest in Libya, 275 of them in Tripoli. Trying to hold power, Muamar Gaddafi takes desperate steps: opposition and deserters were ordered to shoot. The governments of the countries of the European Union are preparing a list of possible sanctions against Libya in connection with the brutal suppression of anti -government speeches in this country. For the "Russian magazine" events in Libya are commented by the director of the Institute of Globalization and Social movements, political analyst Boris Kagarlitsky .

* * *

What we see in Libya is part of the general process of the Arab revolution, perhaps even the Middle Eastern Revolution, which we are now observing the scale of the entire Maghreb. This is only one of the series of revolutionary uprisings that have already begun and will continue for the near future.

Instead of building theories regarding the causes of such a series of uprisings, I advise everyone to take and read the history of Europe of the 19th century . For example, about the revolution of 1848-49. In Europe of that period, we see about the same processes. In the Middle East, finally, the same thing began to happen as in Europe occurred in the middle of the 19th century (in France and in England, however, a little earlier).

The masses first went out into the street, that is, they took a direct part in politics, destroying all political regimes and political structures, including even opposition parties, which, as we see, decay in these countries. Let's see how the events will develop, but it is a really radical fracture, because the very nature of the former existence of the Middle East completely changes, from politics and economics, ending with culture and even the meaning of religion, which is now practically passing away from the life of the Arab world, just as it has passed from the life of European countries, again somewhere in the XVIII-XIX centuries.

The revolution with Islam does the same thing that it has done with Christianity: it removes religion from politics. In this sense, we are observing a democratic revolution. When they say that Islam is a special way of life, a special system of rules and norms, it could be said about Christianity until the middle of the 19th century. And when revolutions occurred, religion automatically lost this function. The same thing is happening in the east now.

The religious Islamic parties themselves do not participate in the revolution. People who are members of these parties are involved, but the parties themselves, as political power, showed their complete incapacity and in fact no longer exist as a single force. No party “Muslim Brothers” is now in Egypt, in fact,. There are many fractions and groups that stood out from it, as, for example, the Socialist Revolutionaries had half a dozen factions during the 1917 revolution. The point is not only that there are no Islamic slogans in the crowd, but there is no way to link what is happening with Islam. People must solve the problem, first of all, the arrangement of representative bodies of government, which would finally reflect the will of the population. People should solve the problem of providing the population with bread - the problem of, apparently, reorienting the economy for the needs of the population. Islam has nothing to do with it at all, he has neither a positive nor a negative attitude to what is happening, he is generally in a different plane.

The nature of the events in Libya is somewhat different from what was happening in other countries. But this is simply due to the level of development of the country, with the level of its political culture. Again, we turn to European history of 1848-49: of course, the events in Hungary did not develop the same as they developed in France, and in Belgium-it is not as in Germany, and even within Germany, in Prussia-not like in Westphalia. In some cases, they were rather bloody, as in Austria and Hungary, in others - less bloody, even less dramatic. Although Europe in the mid -19th century was actually much more cruel than the current Middle East. More people were killed there: somewhere in France 300-400 people were killed a day. However, for those times this was not very serious.

Libya, of course, is a more backward country. This state has its own ethnographic, cultural and ethno -national specifics. Therefore, what to be surprised? Benghazi and Tripoli are two largest cities in the whole country, and a desert between them. This already radically changes the situation to the revolutionary situation, reducing everything to "or-ora." The power in Libya can theoretically try to stay, relying on Tripoli against Benghazi. This will reduce the conflict to the civil war .